Companion Approval in Baldur's Gate 3 are the opinions your Companions make based on the choices you make throughout the game. Players can forge deep connections with the various Companions they encounter to have a positive or a negative opinion, these choices can range from acts of heroism to acts of cruelty, and each decision is met with a corresponding reaction from your Companions. There are various outcomes that could happen with your Companions such as Romancing, and being abandoned or killed by your Companion.      

This page contains a play-by-play per dialogue line that provides approval/disapproval. Extremely detailed spoilers after this point.

 

Companion Approval Guide for Baldur's Gate 3

Baldur's Gate 3 Companion Approval Information

 

Baldur's Gate 3 features a companion approval system that adds depth and complexity to the game's narrative and character interactions. As players progress, you will recruit a diverse cast of characters to join your party, each with their own unique personalities, motivations, and backstories. These companions not only provide valuable assistance during combat encounters but also play a crucial role in shaping the overarching story.

The companion approval system is based on the concept of approval and disapproval, with each character being constantly influenced by the player's actions and choices. How players handle certain situations, interact with NPCs, or resolve conflicts will directly impact their companions' perception of them.

It is important to note that the companion approval system in Baldur's Gate 3 goes beyond a simple binary "good or bad" metric. Each companion has their own unique set of values and morals, and what one companion might see as a positive trait, another may see as negative. This adds a layer of complexity and depth to the choices players make, forcing them to carefully consider the consequences and potential impact on their companions' opinions

Baldur's Gate 3 Romance Explained

 

 

Baldur's Gate 3 Companion Approval Guide

High vs Low Companion Approval in BG3

High companion approval often leads to improved relationships, resulting in companions becoming more loyal, supportive, and effective in combat or other relevant tasks. Increased approval ratings might unlock new quests, dialog options, or even romantic relationships, enhancing the overall gaming experience.

Low companion approval could lead to dissatisfaction, conflicts, or even abandonment from the Companion, potentially removing important allies or reducing certain quest opportunities. Negative actions or decisions might impact the player's reputation in the game, affecting interactions with other NPCs.

Increasing Companion Approval in BG3

Players will need to act in line with the companions' values, beliefs, and aspirations. Pay attention to their personal quests, back stories, and dialogs to understand their preferences better. Frequently engaging in conversations with Companions, asking about their opinions, thoughts, and experiences will help deepen the relationship and gain insights to their likes and dislikes. Make choices in their personal quests or missions, showing genuine interest and investment in their stories and goals.

Players can also offer gifts or complete favors for your companions to improve approval ratings, paying attention to their specific interests or desires for more effective gift giving.

Conflicting Companion Approvals in BG3

In some cases, players might experience having multiple companions whose approval choices conflict with one another, balancing these conflict approvals can be tricky wince decisions that please one companion may upset another. 

Consider the consequences of your actions and make choices based on your own values or the long-term goals of your playthrough. Utilizing dialog options and actions that aim to find compromises, pacify tensions, or even resolve conflicts.

 

 

Companion Character Development in Baldur's Gate 3


As you progress further, due to player choices the companions themselves will start to develop. Larian has painstakingly put a tremendous effort of branching companion morality.


For example Gale can have his morality twisted. If you choose to side with the goblins and unlike Karlach and Wyll, he will not leave your party automatically. Talking to him during the Goblin Party where he will threaten to leave for participating in the massacre of the Refugees. You can convince him to change his morality by justifying his participation was because of his need for survival and effectively stopping him from leaving the party and at the same time twisting his moral compass.

Max Companion Approval in Baldur's Gate 3


When you max out Companion Approval to Exceptional, you will stop gaining Approval Notifications.

It should therefore be noted post Act 1, if you follow the guide then you most likely maxed your preferred companion Approval. Thus there would be situations or choices that may improve your approval but the game does not show.

Distance and Approval in Baldur's Gate 3

  • Companions have a certain distance they need to be in earshot in order to gain approval. Be too far and the Companion will not gain approval.
  • If you leave a companion in camp and out of party, they would also not be able to gain approval or disapproval. The same idea can be said about acts in the Camp (Volo's Surgery)

 

 

 

Act 1
Act 2
Act 3
By Companion

 

Baldur's Gate 3 Dialog Scenarios Quick Navigation

Click to jump to a specific section of the page

Underdark ♦
Grymforge ♦

 

Ravaged Beach/ Nautiloid Crash site

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location
Open Shadowhearts' pod while on the Nautiloid

Requirements/Details:

Shadowheart+ None Dead Mindflayer, Shadowheart Nautiloid Ship- On the way to the Helm, you will encounter a screaming Shadowheart trapped in a mindflayer pod. On the 2nd room of the Tutorial
Tell Astarion "Apology Accepted, I would have done the same"

Requirements/Details:

  • A dialogue line when you meet/try to recruit Astarion
Astarion +Lae'zel +Shadowheart  + Gale - Astarion Ravaged Beach/Nautiloid Crash Site - In the far west of the Ravaged Beach. From the area you wake up, you have to go through the Nautiloid.
Tell Astarion "You'd better have more to offer than apologies"

Requirements/Details:

  • A dialogue line when you meet/try to recruit Astarion
Gale + Shadowheart -  Astarion Ravaged Beach/Nautiloid Crash Site - In the far west of the Ravaged Beach. From the area you wake up, you have to go through the Nautiloid.
Calm the Scared Pig that Astarion Scared. (May Need Speak with Animals)

Requirements/Details:

  • The boar only shows up after Astarion Scares it during this Cutscene. So talk to Astarion and the Boar will appear.
Shadowheart  +Gale   +
Karlach  +
 None Scared Boar Ravaged Beach/Nautiloid Crash Site - Directly South of where you find Astarion.
Persuade the Tieflings to let Lae'zel down

Requirements/Details:

  • First option of persuading the Tieflings to let Lae'zel Down.
  • This however will lead to a situation where you have a choice between helping Lae'zel kill the Tieflings or Help the Tieflings Kill Lae'zel
Shadowheart  + None NymessaDamaysLae'zel Ravaged Beach/Nautiloid Ship - Directly North of the Teleport point where you find Gale. It will be small valley. 
After persuading the Tieflings to let Lae'zel down, Betray the Tieflings

Requirements/Details:

  • After persuading the Tieflings to let Lae'zel down, Betray the Tieflings and start a fight. 
  • YOU DO NOT NEED TO KILL THEM. As the non-lethal combat passive tutorial shows up here.
  • Lae'zel is not a member of your party in this fight and will kill the Tieflings if she lands the last hit.
Astarion  + Gale - NymessaDamaysLae'zel Ravaged Beach/Nautiloid Ship - Directly North of the Teleport point where you find Gale. It will be small valley.
After persuading the Tieflings to let Lae'zel down, Betray Lae'zel

Requirements/Details:

  • After persuading the Tieflings to let Lae'zel down, Betray Lae'zel and join the Tieflings of killing her
Shadowheart+ None NymessaDamaysLae'zel Ravaged Beach/Nautiloid Ship - Directly North of the Teleport point where you find Gale. It will be small valley.
Deceive the Tieflings to make them leave

Requirements/Details:

  • First option of deceiving the Tieflings to leave Lae'zel, which allows you to free her without a fight.
  • The Bard option exaggerates the Nautiloid Ship as scout of an entire invasion force
Gale + None NymessaDamaysLae'zel Ravaged Beach/Nautiloid Ship - Directly North of the Teleport point where you find Gale. It will be small valley. 
Tell Lae'zel to say "Please"

Requirements/Details:

  • Requires you to choose the deceit option with the Tieflings and making them leave.
Shadowheart+, Astarion  + None Lae'zel Ravaged Beach/Nautiloid Ship - Directly North of the Teleport point where you find Gale. It will be small valley. 
Recruit Lae'zel

Requirements/Details:

  • After either killing, knocking out or making the Tieflings leave. You can now talk to Lae'zel and recruit her into the party.
Gale + Shadowheart - Lae'zel Ravaged Beach/Nautiloid Ship - Directly North of the Teleport point where you find Gale. It will be small valley. 
Cast Speak to Dead on the Abducted Nobleman, do the class specific option

Requirements/Details:

  • Requires Speak with Dead Spell. The fastest way is to gain the spell is to have the The Amulet of Lost Voices that can be looted from the Dank Crypt
  • The Cleric option will ask the dead man if he wants a proper burial
  • The Bard option ask the dead man if he wants a song written for him
Karlach  + None Abducted Nobleman's Body Crashed Nautiloid Ship - Will be in the middle of the Ship area where you fight the Intellect Devourers. Will be highlighted if you have the Speak with Dead Spell

Convince the Bandits/Adventurers to leave

Requirements/Details:

  • Win any of the Deception, Intimidation or Persuasion Check to convince the armed group to leave.
  • There seems to be a bug that if you activate the Cutscene from the side entrance rather than the Chapel main entrance the approval will not proc.
Gale + 
Wyll  +, Shadowheart+
 Karlach - Gimblebock and his group. Dank Crypt/Chapel - Directly North-East of the Ravaged Beach. Hard to miss as it is a big structure.

Attack the Bandits/Adventurers

Requirements/Details:

  • Straight up try to Murder them
  • There seems to be a bug that if you activate the Cutscene from the side entrance rather than the Chapel main entrance the approval will not proc.
Wyll  +, Astarion  +Lae'zel  +Karlach  + None Gimblebock  and his group. Dank Crypt/Chapel - Directly North-East of the Ravaged Beach. Hard to miss as it is a big structure.

 

Druid's Grove

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location
Persuade/Intimidate Aradin and Zevlor to calm down

Requirements/Details:

  • Is a Persuasion or Intimidation Skill Check. Not the first persuasion Bard Check. 
Gale + Shadowheart+, Karlach+ None

AradinZevlor

Entrance to the Druid's Gold - Just enter the stone gate after defeating the Goblin Raid.
Punch Aradin or Zevlor

Requirements/Details:

  • Could be an Athletics or Melee Attack Skill roll. Opurtunities may differ depending where the conversation go or if you fail the automatic Insight Check. 

Lae'zel  +

None AradinZevlor  Entrance to the Druid's Gold - Just enter the stone gate after defeating the Goblin Raid.
Refuse to Help Zevlor.

Requirements/Details:

  • Pretty Straightforward. Talk to Zevlor either after calming everyone down, punching Aradin or waking Zevlor after knocking him out.
Shadowheart+Lae'zel  +, Astarion  + None Zevlor Entrance to the Druid's Gold - Just enter the stone gate after defeating the Goblin Raid.
Agree to Help Zevlor

Requirements/Details:

  • Pretty Straightforward. Talk to Zevlor either after calming everyone down, punching Aradin or waking Zevlor after knocking him out.
  • CAN BE TAKEN AFTER REFUSING
  • If you refuse at first during the first talk with Zevlor post Goblin raid, you can accept the quest at a later date by going to the Secluded Sanctum, talking to Zevlor and then agreeing to help the refugees allowing you to farm Approval
Gale Karlach  +Wyll  + Astarion - Zevlor

Entrance to the Druid's Grove - Just enter the stone gate after defeating the Goblin Raid.

Or

Secluded Sanctum - Zevlor own's room within the grove. It is near Dammon and the Couple that is talking about cats

Tell Elegis "You're scared of a few goblins? Pathetic"

Requirements/Details:

  • Simply talk to Elegis after the Goblin Raid
Lae'zel  +, Astarion  + None Elegis Druid Grove - Directly above the Stone Gate. Overlooking the gate,
Deceive/Intimidate Nadira to get the Soul Coin

Requirements/Details:

  • After the Goblin Raid, there will still be some stranglers.
  • In order to have this conversation, Nadira has to be alive. You have to save Nadira from the Bugbear and make sure she is alive.
  • It is recommended to approach from the Goblin Gate Rooftop as approaching it from the Squirrel/Elevator are can trigger the bugbear attack and get Nadira Killed.
  • After Saving Nadira, simply Intimdate or Deceive her into giving the Soul Coin with Shadowheart
Shadowheart+  None Nadira  Druid Grove - Directly above the Stone Gate.  There is a hilltop on the far east of side of the Gate.
Tell Rolan, Lia and Cal to "GET OUT WHILE YOU CAN"

Requirements/Details:

  • The Trio of Rolan, Lia and Cal will be having a conversation weather to stay and fight wit the refugees or run for Baldur's Gate
Shadowheart+ None RolanLia and Cal  Druid Grove - Right next to the Druid trader.
Convince Rolan to Stay and fight for the Tieflings

Requirements/Details:

  • The Trio of Rolan, Lia and Cal will be having a conversation weather to stay and fight wit the refugees or run for Baldur's Gate
Gale +  None RolanLia and Cal  Druid Grove - Right next to the Druid trader.
Talk to Rolan with Gale and arrange for a meeting with Lorroakan

Requirements/Details:

  • Requires RolanLia and Cal to stay and fight
  • Requires Gale to be in Party while talking to Rolan.
Gale +   None RolanLia and Cal Druid Grove - Campfire in front of the Auntie Ethel and the lady feeding the Camp.

When Recruiting Wyll, say you will join his crusade

Requirements/Details:

None Lae'zel - Wyll Druid Grove - Wyll in the Training Area

Finish Recruiting Wyll

Requirements/Details:

Gale + None  Wyll Druid Grove - Wyll in the Training Area

Stand between Arka's Crossbow and Sazza

Requirements/Details:

  • First Choice in the Interaction to the event.
Gale + None SazzaArka  Druid Grove - Makeshift Prison, far end in the North Westerten part of the Druid Grove, Tiefling Area.

Let Arka Kill Sazza

Requirements/Details:

  • Let her shoot the Goblin
Wyll  +, Astarion  +Lae'zel  + Karlach - SazzaArka Druid Grove - Makeshift Prison, far end in the North Westerten part of the Druid Grove, Tiefling Area.

Convince Arka not to Kill Sazza

Requirements/Details:

  • Win the Persuasion, Intimidation or any way to stop her from shooting.
Gale +
Shadowheart+
Karlach  +
Wyll -
Lae'zel -
SazzaArka Druid Grove - Makeshift Prison, far end in the North Westerten part of the Druid Grove, Tiefling Area.

Agree to break Sazza out.

Requirements/Details:

  • Pretty Straightforward
Karlach  + Wyll -
Lae'zel -
Sazza Druid Grove - Makeshift Prison, far end in the North Westerten part of the Druid Grove, Tiefling Area.

After saving Findal from the Band of Goblins, inform him that "Don't thank me yet. I'm here to finish what they started"

Requirements/Details:

  • Pretty Straightforward
Astarion + Gale - Findal Druid GroveUnderground Passage - Can be accessed by a small platforming/jumping route from the the makeshift prison in Tiefling Area/Hollow or from a locked door from the Emerald Grove

Tell Auntie Ethel about the Tagpole in the Tiefling Camp

Requirements/Details:

Astarion  +  Lae'zel - 
Shadowheart -
Auntie Ethel Druid Grove - Tiefling Market area. Near Dammon and the Canteen

When Asharak ask you to say something, "Bad News Kids, You are all going to die."

Requirements/Details:

  • Asharak the trainer will ask the heroes of the Goblin Raid to say a few thing to trainning Children
Lae'zel  +
Astarion  +
Gale -
Wyll -
Karlach -
Asharak and group children Tiefling Druid Grove - Makeshift training area in the middle of the Tiefling Camp. Very Noisy and hard to miss.

Help Guex with his Swordfighting

Requirements/Details:

  • You can help him multiple ways. 
  • By using an Athletics Roll
  • By using an Insight Roll
  • Or if you have Detect Thoughts which unlocks a secret dialogue
Lae'zel  +
Gale +
Wyll   +
Karlach  +
Shadowheart+
 None Guex Druid Grove - Makeshift training area in the middle of the Tiefling Camp. Very Noisy and hard to miss.

Tell Guex to not shout his moves

Requirements/Details:

  • Straight forward choice after helping Guex. No need to roll. Pretty hard to mixx
Lae'zel  +
Wyll  +
None Guex Druid Grove - Makeshift training area in the middle of the Tiefling Camp. Very Noisy and hard to miss.

Tell Zorru to Follow Lae'zel's orders

Requirements/Details:

  • Just follow Lae'zel's leads in the conversation
Lae'zel  +
Astarion  +
Shadowheart -
Karlach -
Zorru Druid Grove - Area between the Makeshift Prison And  Tiefling common area/Training Area. Usuallly but Zorru Moves around alot and I saw him sometimes next to the stone door to the Secluded Sanctum.

Compliment Lae'zel interrogation of Zorru

Requirements/Details:

  • Talk to Lae'zel after the interrogation.
Lae'zel  +
Astarion  +
Shadowheart -
Karlach -
Zorru Druid Grove - Area between the Makeshift Prison And  Tiefling common area/Training Area. Usuallly but Zorru Moves around alot and I saw him sometimes next to the stone door to the Secluded Sanctum.

Take Mattis ring

Requirements/Details:

  • Mattis, the Child Tiefling and scammer will offer you are ring during his performance trick. 
  • Keep the ring no matter how much he begs
Astarion  + Karlach - Mattis Druid Grove - The small cave like passage between the Druid area and Tiefling Area. Impossible to miss.

Detect Silfy's pickpocket with a perception check and let her go in the nicest way.

Requirements/Details:

  • Actually extremely hard to pull as you require someon with enough Wisdom or Perception bonus strong enough to pass the Perception Check
  • The Perception Check is automatic so Inspiration Rerolls are not allowed.
  • You need to stay long enough for Silfy to try her pickpocket. Open Mattis store is enough for this.
  • If your main character sucks at Wisdom, use Shadowheart. She does not have an approval in this scene and she is built for Wisdom due to being a Cleric. 
  • You need to talk to Mattis to start the Scene and happens right after you leave his conversation.
  • After passing the Perception Check, you need to choose the nicest option of letting Silfy go. The one that does not have a skill check
Gale +
Karlach  +
Wyll  +
Astarion -
Lae'zel -
Silfy Druid Grove - The small cave like passage between the Druid area and Tiefling Area. Impossible to miss.

After dealing with Kagha, agree to help deal with the Goblins for Zevlor and the Tieflings

Requirements/Details:

  • Can be done after exposing Kagha's Conspiracy. 
  • It might be possible to do this if you kill Kagha or Bring back Halsin but have not Personally confirmed
Karlach  +
Wyll  +
Astarion - Zevlor Druid GroveSecluded Sanctum - Just enter the stone door in the Hollow/Tiefling area

After dealing with Kagha, telll Zevlor you don't care about his other problem

Requirements/Details:

  • Can be done after exposing Kagha's Conspiracy. 
  • It might be possible to do this if you kill Kagha or Bring back Halsin but have not Personally confirmed
Astarion  + Wyll -
Karlach -
Zevlor Druid GroveSecluded Sanctum - Just enter the stone door in the Hollow/Tiefling area

Offer to Heal Pandirna without pay (Bard/Relevant Classes)

Requirements/Details:

  • First win the Skill roll to pacify her when she catches you.
  • Do not take the Intimidation Skill check as she will just be shaken in fear to engage in conversation.
  • Pandirna is Paralysed and needs lesser restoration to be healed
  • I have seen clerics with this option as well but have not tested for every spell caster
  • Paladins Confirmed to have this option as well
Karlach  + ,
Gale +
?? Pandirna  Druid Grove, The Storeroom - Pandirna is stuck inside the Storeroom, a locked roon in front of the Trainning area.

Can be accessed from the behind in the area near the door leading to the Underground Passage, skipping the risky lockpicking.

Offer to Heal Pandirna with pay (Bard/Paladin/Cleric) and then pocket the money and leave.

Requirements/Details:

  • First win the Skill roll to pacify her when she catches you.
  • Do not take the Intimidation Skill check as she will just be shaken in fear to engage in conversation.
  • Pandirna is Paralysed and needs lesser restoration to be healed
  • I have seen clerics with this option as well but have not tested for every spell caster
  • Paladins Confirmed to have this option as well
Astarion + ?? Pandirna Druid Grove, The Storeroom - Pandirna is stuck inside the Storeroom, a locked roon in front of the Trainning area.

Can be accessed from the behind in the area near the door leading to the Underground Passage, skipping the risky lockpicking.
While talking to Arabella's Parents , Blame them for Arabella's situation

Requirement/s:

  • Hard not to encounter as they will have a cutscene with the Druid's guarding area.
  • You have to talk to them before resolving Arabella's situation with Kagha for obvious reasons to get this dialogue
None Karlach - Locke and Komira Druid's Grove - The Stone steps entering into the Druid area.
While talking to Arabella's Parents , promise to help

Requirement/s:

  • Hard not to encounter as they will have a cutscene with the Druid's guarding area.
  • You have to talk to them before resolving Arabella's situation with Kagha for obvious reasons to get this dialogue
Gale +
Karlach  +
Wyll  +
Astarion - Locke and Komira Druid's Grove - The Stone steps entering into the Druid area.
Use the Deceit option with Topaz the Bird

Requirement/s:

  • Pretty Straight forward. Win the Deceit Roll
Karlach  
Shadowheart+
  Topaz Druid's Grove - The little nest on the ground next to the elevator.
Use the bard option with Topaz the Bird

Requirement/s:

  • Might be class restricted. A lot of class specific dialouge have their own equivalent but I only tested this with a Bard Character.
Karlach  +
Astarion  +
Shadowheart+
None Topaz Druid's Grove - The little nest on the ground next to the elevator.
Use the Intimidate option with Topaz the Bird

Requirement/s:

  • Pretty Straight forward. Win the Intimidate Roll
Karlach  +
Astarion  +
None Topaz

Druid's Grove - The little nest on the ground next to the elevator.

Help Alfira finish her song

Requirement/s:

  • This is a unique chance to get a character to be able to learn how to play a musical instrument
Karlach  
Gale + 
Wyll  +
None Alfira Druid's Grove - After going down the stone steps towards the ritual area. Near Volo's interview area with the bear is a pathway. The road leading north that leads to the beach area and the other path leading south where Alfira is trying to finish her song.
Persuade Kagha to free Arabella

Requirement/s:

  • Automatic cutscenes when you enter the Emerald Grove.
  • Simply win one of the many multiple Skill Check rolls to stop Kagha from harming Arabella.
  • If you use the Detect Thoughts method, Astarion will not disapprove but Lae'zel will still do so.
Gale +
Shadowheart+
Wyll  +
Karlach  +
Lae'zel -
Astarion -
Kagha Druid GroveEmerald Grove - Special Area where the Druid Leadership are. Can be accessed by a door next to the Ritual Area.
Tell Kagha she is a monster in the dialogue after the Arabella event

Requirement/s:

  • Weather Arabella Dies or not, most of the dialogue will be the same
Wyll  +
Gale  +
Karlach  +
None Kagha Druid GroveEmerald Grove - Special Area where the Druid Leadership are. Can be accessed by a door next to the Ritual Area.
Tell Kagha you enjoyed her show after she asks if you think she's a monster.

Requirement/s:

  • Weather Arabella Dies or not, most of the dialogue will be the same
Astarion  + Wyll - Kagha Druid GroveEmerald Grove - Special Area where the Druid Leadership are. Can be accessed by a door next to the Ritual Area.
Tell Kagha "She was just protecting her own." after the Arabella event

Requirement/s:

  • Weather Arabella Dies or not, most of the dialogue will be the same
Lae'zel  +
Shadowheart+
Karlach - 
Wyll -
Kagha Druid GroveEmerald Grove - Special Area where the Druid Leadership are. Can be accessed by a door next to the Ritual Area.
Tell Kagha "I wanted to see what happen" after the Arabella event

Requirement/s:

  • One of the few Dialogue different depending on what happens with Arabella
 ?? Karlach - 
Wyll -
  Druid GroveEmerald Grove - Special Area where the Druid Leadership are. Can be accessed by a door next to the Ritual Area.
After letting Arabella die, lie to Komira and Locke that she is fine.

Requirement/s:

  • Lie to the worried couple about the death of their child
Astarion  
Lae'zel +
?? Locke and Komira Druid Grove, - Stone steps entering the Druid Ritual Area.
Prod the bird to death

Requirement/s:

  • Force the Bird to talk, causing it to die
Astarion  + Karlach -  ?? Druid GroveEmerald Grove - Nettie's work space where she is tending to the bird and wheer you first meet her.
Let Silver the Wolf smell you

Requirement/s:

  • With Speak with Animals, Talk to Silver the Wolf and just let him acquire your scent
  • Shadowheart will have special dialogue after this scene explaining how she has a phobia wth Wolves (Explained further during her Flashback)
Shadowheart 
Karlach + 
Wyll +
Gale +
  Silver Druid GroveEmerald Grove - Meeting Area where Kagha and Rath hangout.
Swear to take Nettie Poison

Requirement/s:

  • Agree to her terms
Lae'zel  +
Shadowheart +
Astarion -
Karlach -
Nettie Druid GroveEmerald Grove - Nettie/Halsin's secret research area. Just follow Nettie
Tell Kagha you will kill her for Zevlor

Requirement/s:

  • Will start a war between the druids and Tieflings
Wyll  +
Karlach  +
Astarion  +
   Kagha Druid GroveEmerald Grove - Special Area where the Druid Leadership are. Can be accessed by a door next to the Ritual Area.
After Exposing Kagha's Conspiracy, choose to fight Kagha

Requirement/s:

  • Requires you to find the letter of Kagha implicating her with the Shadow Druids. Can be found in the Sunlit Wetlands coast/port within the Large Dead tree
  • The Investigation can be started by finding, Kagha's secret Stash. It is hidden behind a wall but easily accessible from 2nd room in the Emerald Grove.
Wyll  +
Karlach  +
Astarion  +
none Kagha
Rath
Ogaden
Druid GroveEmerald Grove - Special Area where the Druid Leadership are. Can be accessed by a door next to the Ritual Area.
After Exposing Kagha's Conspiracy, convince Kagha to side against the Shadow Druids

Requirement/s:

  • Requires you to find the letter of Kagha implicating her with the Shadow Druids. Can be found in the Sunlit Wetlands coast/port within the Large Dead tree
  • The Investigation can be started by finding, Kagha's secret Stash. It is hidden behind a wall but easily accessible from 2nd room in the Emerald Grove.
Wyll  +
Karlach  
Gale +
Astarion  -  Kagha
Rath
Ogaden
Druid GroveEmerald Grove - Special Area where the Druid Leadership are. Can be accessed by a door next to the Ritual Area.

After saving the child from the Harpies, tell them "Stop snivelling or they'll be back. They like tasty little tiefling kids."

Astarion +     Druid Grove, Secluded Grove

 

Forest/Owlbear Nest

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location

Tell Edowin Siblings to leave

Requirements/Details:

  • After encountering the dying Edowin and his siblings. Do not reveal that you are not a member of the cult of the absolute.
Shadowheart  + None Edowin
Brynna
Andrick
Area between Blighted Village and Druid Grove/The Forest - Before the bridge and river seperating the Blighted Village and Druid Grove. Facing the bridge, take the road to the right.

Tell Edowin Siblings, "Im a survivor of that crash"

Requirements/Details:

  • After encountering the dying Edowin and his siblings. Do not reveal that you are not a member of the cult of the absolute.
Lae'zel  + None Edowin
Brynna
Andrick
Area between Blighted Village and Druid Grove/The Forest - Before the bridge and river seperating the Blighted Village and Druid Grove. Facing the bridge, take the road to the right.

Tell Edowin Siblings to fight owlbear

Requirements/Details:

  • After encountering the dying Edowin and his siblings. Do not reveal that you are not a member of the cult of the absolute.
Lae'zel  +
Astarion  +
None Edowin
Brynna
Andrick
Area between Blighted Village and Druid Grove/The Forest - Before the bridge and river seperating the Blighted Village and Druid Grove. Facing the bridge, take the road to the right.

Leave Selûnite Treasure Untouched

Requirements/Details:

  • If Shadowheart is in the party she tells you not to take any of the treasure in the enchanted chest by the shrine. Allowing her to talk you out of it receives her approval (+5).
  • Successfully Persuading/Intimidating her allows you to take the treasure without approval penalty. Failing to do so earns disapproval (-5).
  • Agreeing not to take the treasure and then attempting to do so will prompt a Slight of Hand roll. Failing the check earns (-2) approval, still netting a (+3) overall.
  • If you agree to leave the treasure, then return without Shadowheart in your party, you can take the treasure without consequence.
 Shadowheart +  None   Owlbear Nest - Shrine of Selûne, lower falls area

Convince the Owlbear to let you go

Requirements/Details:

  • You can still end up in a fight with the Owlbear if you come too close. If you want to loot the cave, you will have to kill the Fully grown owlbear
Gale  +
Shadowheart  +
Karlach  +
Lae'zel - Owlbear Cub
Owlbear
Owlbear Nest - Far end of the Cave
Let owlbear Cub live

Requirements/Details:

  • You can still end up in a fight with the Owlbear if you come too close even after convincing it to let you go. If you want to loot the cave, you will have to kill the Fully grown owlbear
Gale +
Shadowheart  +
Wyll  +
Karlach  +
None Owlbear Cub
Owlbear
Owlbear Nest - Far end of the Cave

Kill the Cub, Dialogue choice

Requirements/Details:

  • You can still end up in a fight with the Owlbear if you come too close even after convincing it to let you go. If you want to loot the cave, you will have to kill the Fully grown owlbear
Lae'zel  + Shadowheart -
Gale -
Karlach -
Owlbear Cub
Owlbear
Owlbear Nest - Far end of the Cave

Inviting Scratch to your camp if his friend do not wake up.

Requirements/Details:

  • Convince Scratch you are friendly
 Shadowheart  +
Wyll  
Karlach  +
none Scratch Forest - North Forest Areat near the entrance to the Blighted village. Directly West of the Owlbear Cave entrance

 

 

Blighted Village

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location

Convince the Goblin Ambushers to let you pass

Requirements/Details:

  • There are multiple skills that can be used which includes Persuasion, Intimidate and or Illithid. Just pass one to get the instance
Shadowheart + None Goblin Ambushers Blighted Village - You start the encounter with the goblin ambushers as soon as you enter the Village

Attack the Goblin Ambushers

Requirements/Details:

  • Choose to attack the Goblin Ambushers
Astarion  + None Goblin Ambushers Blighted Village - You start the encounter with the goblin ambushers as soon as you enter the Village

Convince Freezerk to not Fight you

Requirements/Details:

  • Simply win the Skill role to convince him to Stand down
Karlach  +
Gale +
Shadowheart+
None Freezerk Blighted Village - Windmill Area, follow the sound of a screaming Deep Gnome. From the main entrance of the Village coming from the Druid Grove. Simply follow the main road till you see the Windmill
Attack Freezerk first chance you get

Requirements/Details:

  • Choose to attack the Freezerk and his gang first chance you get.
Wyll  +
Lae'zel  +
Shadowheart - Freezerk Blighted Village - Windmill Area, follow the sound of a screaming Deep Gnome. From the main entrance of the Village coming from the Druid Grove. Simply follow the main road till you see the Windmill

Execute Freezerk after surrender

Requirements/Details:

  • For this encounter to happen, you need to make Freezerk Surrender. And that will require to kill atleast one goblin that is not Freezerk and getting freezerk to below 30% but not kill him. (Be careful with high damage or just use non-lethal damage)
Wyll  +
Lae'zel  +
Shadowheart+
Karlach - Freezerk Blighted Village - Windmill Area, follow the sound of a screaming Deep Gnome. From the main entrance of the Village coming from the Druid Grove. Simply follow the main road till you see the Windmill

Let Freezerk Go

Requirements/Details:

  • For this encounter to happen, you need to make Freezerk Surrender. And that will require to kill atleast one goblin that is not Freezerk and getting freezerk to below 30% but not kill him. (Be careful with high damage or just use non-lethal damage)
None Shadowheart -
Wyll -
Astarion -
Freezerk Blighted Village - Windmill Area, follow the sound of a screaming Deep Gnome. From the main entrance of the Village coming from the Druid Grove. Simply follow the main road till you see the Windmill

Tell the Deep Gnome Barcus Wroot you want compensation

Requirements/Details:

  • Choose to not kill Barcus by pulling the brake lever on the windmill and talking to Barcus right after freeing him.
Astarion   +
Shadowheart+
Wyll - Barcus Wroot Blighted Village - Windmill Area, follow the sound of a screaming Deep Gnome. From the main entrance of the Village coming from the Druid Grove. Simply follow the main road till you see the Windmill

Convince the ogres to side with you

Requirements/Details:

  • First you have to win the Deceit Roll to be able to open the possibility of hiring them
  • Win any of the skill roles needed to hire the Ogres.
Karlach  +
Shadowheart+
None Lump the Enlightened Blighted Village - The last house before the South Entrance of the Village. The building is the former school and hard to miss.

 

Sunlit Wetlands (Putrid Bog)

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location
Tell Johl and Demir that you will save Mayrina

Requirement/s:

  • Choose the Option that exposes Ethel but not kill the Brothers. 
  • This dialogue choice becomes available after Auntie Ethel disappears
Karlach  +
Gale +
Wyll  +
Shadowheart -
Lae'zel -
Auntie Ethel, Johl and Demir Sunlit Wetlands - Hard to miss if you use the road as they are right in the entrance into the Sunlit Wetlands from the Blighted Village
Tell Johl and Demir that they are on their own

Requirement/s:

  • Choose the Option that exposes Ethel but not kill the Brothers. 
  • This dialogue choice becomes available after Auntie Ethel disappears
Shadowheart
Lae'zel
 +
Astarion  +
Wyll - Auntie EthelJohl and Demir Sunlit Wetlands - Hard to miss if you use the road as they are right in the entrance into the Sunlit Wetlands from the Blighted Village
Say Bah to the Redcap

Requirement/s:

  • Requires breaking the Illusion in the Swamp to see the Redcaps. 
  • To break the Illusion, either win the DC 20 Perception Check or Talk to the Addled Frog. There may be other methods to break the Illusions
  • Can be repeated once with another redcap. The approval stacks
Shadowheart+
Astarion  +
Karlach  +
None Any Redcap or Redcap Blood Sage Sunlit Wetlands - In the middle of the Sunlit Wetlands next to the waypoint. If you do not break the Illusion they will appear to be sheep and respond with Baaah even if you try to talk to them with Speak with Animals
To Gandrel without Astarion , Say Astarion is under my Protection

Requirement/s:

  • Do Not Bring Astarion when you meet Gandrel
  • After convincing Gandrel to share his mission. Say this line.
Gale +
Karlach  +
Lae'zel - Gandrel Sunlit Wetlands - The Hill next to the Waypoint, just climb up the steps and find him.
To Gandrel without Astarion , tell him to back off

Requirement/s:

  • Do Not Bring Astarion when you meet Gandrel
  • After convincing Gandrel to share his mission. Say this line. Comes after the dialogue line of saying Astarion is under protection and can stack approval with the previous line.
Gale +
Karlach  +
Lae'zel - Gandrel Sunlit Wetlands - The Hill next to the Waypoint, just climb up the steps and find him.
To Gandrel without Astarion , tell him camp location

Requirement/s:

  • Do Not Bring Astarion when you meet Gandrel
  • After convincing Gandrel to share his mission. Say this line.
Lae'zel  + Gale -
Karlach -
Gandrel Sunlit Wetlands - The Hill next to the Waypoint, just climb up the steps and find him.
To Gandrel with Astarion , kill Gandrel

Requirement/s:

Astarion  + Karlach -
Lae'zel -
Gandrel Sunlit Wetlands - The Hill next to the Waypoint, just climb up the steps and find him. If Astarion has not yet revealed himself as a vampire spawn to you, he will kill Gandrel on his own, and you will not receive any approval changes.
To Gandrel witht Astarion , do not kill gandrel

Requirement/s:

Shadowheart+ Astarion - Gandrel Sunlit Wetlands - The Hill next to the Waypoint, just climb up the steps and find him.
To Gandrel with Astarion , reveal Astarion

Requirement/s:

Lae'zel  + Astarion -
Gale -
Karlach -
Gandrel Sunlit Wetlands - The Hill next to the Waypoint, just climb up the steps and find him.
Drink from the well outside of Auntie Ethel's teahouse (well coords -35,251) Gale
Lae'zel  +
   

Riverside Teahouse - Slightly southeast of frontdoor entrance to teahouse

NOTE: Not tested for all companions. Party of Gale/Karlack/Shadowheart only gave approval to Gale.

Receive Mayrina's Locket

  • Save Mayrina

Requirements;

  • You need to let Mayrina know Ethel killed her Brothers. This can only be triggered the first time you encounter Mayrina when Ethel is forcing her to eat Hag Food.
  • When you kill Ethel / Ask Ethel to save Mayrina at the Overgrown Tunnel, you can talk to her after the battle and pick the Third/3rd Option when she wants to give you something
Shadowheart   Auntie Ethel Mayrina

Sunlit Wetlands - Auntie Ethel's Teahouse. Cutscene will play when you meet her at the door.

Overgrown Tunnel - Very end boss area where you fight Ethel again

Keep Asking about Mayrina when talking to Ethel

Requirement/s:

  • Just keep asking about Mayrina.
  • Technically only needs the last dialogue line that will start a fight but Ethel will try to steer the conversation away from her so this is the easiest way to gain this Dialouge.
Gale +
Karlach  +
Wyll  +
Astarion - Auntie Ethel Mayrina Sunlit Wetlands - Auntie Ethel's Teahouse. Cutscene will play when you meet her at the door.
Let Mayrina Know that her brothers are dead.

Requirement/s:

  • Mayrina brothers needs to be dead.
  • Either Kill them in the initial Encounter, do not kill them but say you will help them so they will die in the swamp
Gale +
Wyll +
Karlach +
 Astarion -  Auntie Ethel  Sunlit Wetlands - Auntie Ethel's Teahouse. Cutscene will play when you meet her at the door.
 Agree to Ethel's deal

Requirement/s:

  • When Auntie Ethel offer to remove the tadpole, take it. 
None Lae'zel -
Shadowheart -
Wyll -
Auntie Ethel Sunlit Wetlands - Auntie Ethel's Teahouse. Cutscene will play when you meet her at the door.
Agree to Ethel's deal and give her an eye

Requirement/s:

  • When Auntie Ethel offer to remove the tadpole, take it. She will fail but you get an Intimidation buff and perception debuff in exchange.
None Lae'zel -
Wyll -
Auntie Ethel Sunlit Wetlands - Auntie Ethel's Teahouse. Cutscene will play when you meet her at the door.
Pretend to be a Mindflayer and roar at Lorin

Requirement/s:

  • Roar and pretened to be a mindflayer to scare the poor Elf.
Lae'zel  +
Shadowheart+
Astarion  +
Wyll - Lorin Overgrown Tunnel - He is next to the talking door
Convince a Surrendered Hag Ethel to let Mayrina go and give you power

Requirement/s:

  • In order to Make Ethel surrender, you need to damage her enough without killing her. The Cutscenes usually procs at around 10-15% health and activates when it is her turn.
  • It is advised to keep your high Charisma character to be close to Ethel at the fight as she would initiate conversation with the nearest Player Character and because you would need to pass a DC 20 Deceit or Intimidate Check to get succeed in this dialogue line
Karlach  +
Astarion  +
Lae'zel  +
Shadowheart
None

Auntie Ethel , Mayrina

Overgrown Tunnel - Very end boss area where you fight Ethel again
With a Surrendered Hag Ethel choose Mayrina's Freedom

Requirement/s:

  • In order to Make Ethel surrender, you need to damage her enough without killing her. The Cutscenes usually procs at around 10-15% health and activates when it is her turn.
Gale +
Kalach  +
Shadowheart -
Astarion -
Lae'zel -
Auntie Ethel ,Mayrina Overgrown Tunnel - Very end boss area where you fight Ethel again
With a Surrendered Hag Ethel choose to execute Ethel

Requirement/s:

  • In order to Make Ethel surrender, you need to damage her enough without killing her. The Cutscenes usually procs at around 10-15% health and activates when it is her turn.
  • Auntie Ethel already mentions she has a revive method so she will still appear in Act 3 even if you kill her.
Gale +
Karlach  +
Wyll  +
Lae'zel  +
Shadowheart+
Astarion - Auntie EthelMayrina Overgrown Tunnel - Very end boss area where you fight Ethel again
With a Surrendered Hag Ethel choose the gift of power and let her take Mayrina

Requirement/s:

  • In order to Make Ethel surrender, you need to damage her enough without killing her. The Cutscenes usually procs at around 10-15% health and activates when it is her turn.
Shadowheart+
Astarion  +
Gale -
Karlach -
Wyll -
Auntie EthelMayrina Overgrown Tunnel - Very end boss area where you fight Ethel again
Give the Second Marriage Wand and Zombie Connor to Mayrina

Requirement/s:

  • Mayrina need to be freed by Ethel or Ethel being dead
  • Require picking up the Second Marriage Wand in Ethel's Loot room
Gale +
Karlach  
Wyll +
None Mayrina Sunlit Wetlands - Next to the Teahouse and in Front of Connor's Casket. If you use the Mushroom Portal, impossible to miss.
Attack the Zombie Connor

Requirement/s:

  • Mayrina need to be freed by Ethel or Ethel being dead
  • Require picking up the Second Marriage Wand in Ethel's Loot room
Gale + None Mayrina Sunlit Wetlands - Next to the Teahouse and in Front of Connor's Casket. If you use the Mushroom Portal, impossible to miss.
Keep the Second Marriage Wand and Zombie Connor

Requirement/s:

  • Mayrina need to be freed by Ethel or Ethel being dead
  • Require picking up the Second Marriage Wand in Ethel's Loot room
None Wyll - Mayrina Sunlit Wetlands - Next to the Teahouse and in Front of Connor's Casket. If you use the Mushroom Portal, impossible to miss.

 

Risen Road (Waukeen's Rest and Mountain Pass)

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location
With Wyll when meeting Karlach, tell Wyll to kill Karlach

Requirement/s:

  • Will activate if you first meet Karlach with Wyll in the party.
  • This encounter will happen in Camp if you recruit Karlach without Wyll in the party.
Wyll  + None Karlach

Risen Road - Far Right Side/South West of the Area by the river. Indicated by Wyll's Quest. 

or

Camp - Long Rest with Karlach and Wyll recruited

Wyll when meeting Karlach, tell Wyll Karlach is no danger

Requirement/s:

  • Will activate if you first meet Karlach with Wyll in the party.
  • This encounter will happen in Camp if you recruit Karlach without Wyll in the party. The dialogue will proc if Karlach and Wyll is recruited and long rest for the evening
  • It is recomended to do this scene in Camp as every Companion will like it if you defend Karlach. Including Wyll and Karlach
Wyll  +
Shadowheart+
Gale +
Lae'zel  +
Astarion  +
Karlach  +
None Karlach

Risen Road - Far Right Side/South West of the Area by the river. Indicated by Wyll's Quest. 

or

Camp - Long Rest with Karlach and Wyll recruited

Use the (Cleric) option to bless the sick Hyena you encounter

Requirement/s:

Gale 
Karlach +
None Hyena about to turn into a Gnoll

Risen Road - The location where the dead bodies and sick hyena is. Close by the Bridge entering the Risen Road and directly to its East

Use Illithid powers on Flind to force her to attack her pack

Requirement/s:

  • The dialogue will proc during Flind's 2nd turn after moving or attacking when combat starts.
  • The Player Character Flind will talk to would be the closest party member.
  • It is recommended to have a character that has a high Wisdom like Shadowheart or a Wisdom build character as this will be a difficult wisdom roll.
Gale +
Astarion  +
Karlach - Flind The Risen Road - Cave Entrance in the middle of the Risen Road. Follow the blood and trail of Dead bodies.
Use Illithid powers on The Head Gnoll to attack Rugan and Olly

Requirement/s:

  • The dialogue will proc during Flind's 2nd turn after moving or attacking when combat starts.
  • The Player Character Flind will talk to would be the closest party member.
  • It is recommended to have a character that has a high Wisdom like Shadowheart or a Wisdom build character as this will be a difficult wisdom roll.
Astarion  + None Flind The Risen Road - Cave Entrance in the middle of the Risen Road. Follow the blood and trail of Dead bodies.
Conjure the mewlings of easy prey into The Head Gnoll's mind, causing her to attack Rugan and Olly. [Bard]
  • Find the Missing Shipment

    Requirement/s:

  • This option is only available to Bards and requires a Performance check.
  • The dialogue will start during combat as soon as Flind is in close range of a character.
Astarion + None Flind The Risen Road - Cave Entrance in the middle of the Risen Road. Follow the blood and trail of Dead bodies.
After Battle, Convince the Gnoll to eat herself

Requirement/s:

  • Flind must be convinced to attack her pack
  • Has two Wisdom DC rolls with an extremely high DC (15)
  • The Player Character Flind will talk to would be the closest party member.
  • It is recommended to have a character that has a high Wisdom like Shadowheart or a Wisdom build character as this will be a difficult wisdom roll.
Gale +
Astarion  +
Karlach - Flind The Risen Road - Cave Entrance in the middle of the Risen Road. Follow the blood and trail of Dead bodies.
Convince Rugan to give you the Chest

Requirement/s:

  • Straight up Persuasion Roll
  • If you go to the Zhentarim Hideout right after, Olly will be dead and Rugan tortures as the Zhentarim will know they were betrayed
Shadowheart  +
Karlach  +
Gale +
None Rugan

The Risen Road - Cave Entrance in the middle of the Risen Road. Follow the blood and trail of Dead bodies.

Refuse to help search for Duke Ravenguard

Requirement/s:

  • If you long rest after activating the burning Inn event, the flaming fist will break the door and rescue the Counsellor without your help and you will miss this instance
Astarion  + Wyll -
Karlach -
Counsellor Florrick
Gauntlet Yeva

The Risen Road - From the Broken Bridge coming from the direction of the Blighted Village, just head generally west and you will encounter Waukeen's Rest Inn Burning.

Agree to help search for Duke Ravenguard

Requirement/s:

  • If you long rest after activating the burning Inn event, the flaming fist will break the door and rescue the Counsellor without your help and you will miss this instance
Wyll  +
Karlach  +
Gale +
Astarion - Counsellor Florrick
Gauntlet Yeva

The Risen Road - From the Broken Bridge coming from the direction of the Blighted Village, just head generally west and you will encounter Waukeen's Rest Inn Burning.

Help Benryn, stuck in the fire.

Requirement/s:

  • When you break a pathway into Benryn's room, there would be small explosion of the wall in between him and the burning room starting the spread of fire into the room where he is stuck.
  • If you long rest after activating the burning Inn event, the fire will probably spread enough and kill Benryn thus making this dialouge missable.
Wyll  +
Karlach  +
Gale +
None Benryn

The Risen Road - From the Broken Bridge coming from the direction of the Blighted Village, just head generally west and you will encounter Waukeen's Rest Inn Burning.

Give Benryn the Dowry

Requirement/s:

  • After Rescuing Benryn and after finding the Dowry
Karlach +    Benryn The Risen Road - From the Broken Bridge coming from the direction of the Blighted Village, just head generally west and you will encounter Waukeen's Rest Inn Burning.

Persuade the Zhentarim to let you in. 

Requirement/s:

  • Can only be done if Rugan has not arrived.
Gale +
Karlach  +
Shadowheart +
None Zherys The Risen RoadZhentarim Basement - In Waukeen's Rest Barn/Basement. Go to the farm area and go through the Doorway blocked by boxes, get through the guard and get to the Hideout

Kill Rugan 

Requirement/s:

  • If you Persuade Rugan to hand over the Chest to you, Zherys will find out.
  • Once you end up in the Hideout, Rugan will be strapped to a chair tortured and Olle will be dead.
  • You can run a Skill Check (Persuade/Intimidate) in order to convince Zherys to allow you to live and finish the Job but you have to kill Rugan.
  • IF YOU OPEN THE CHEST, THE ONLY OPTION IS TO KILL EVERYONE IN THE ZHENTARIM HIDEOUT
Astarion +
Shadowhert +
Karlach - Zherys The Risen RoadZhentarim Basement - In Waukeen's Rest Barn/Basement. Go to the farm area and go through the Doorway blocked by boxes, get through the guard and get to the Hideout

Intimidate Bren for a discount on Oskar

Requirement/s:

  • Pass the high intimidation roll to force Bren  for a discount.
Gale +
Karlach +
Shadowheart +
Wyll +
Lae'zel +
None BrenOskar The Risen RoadZhentarim Basement - In Waukeen's Rest Barn/Basement. Go to the farm area and go through the Doorway blocked by boxes, get through the guard and get to the Hideout

Buy Oskar

Requirement/s:

  • Spend the money. 1000 without the discount, 600 if you managed to get a discount
Gale +
Karlach +
Wyll +
Astarion -
Lae'zel -
BrenOskar The Risen RoadZhentarim Basement - In Waukeen's Rest Barn/Basement. Go to the farm area and go through the Doorway blocked by boxes, get through the guard and get to the Hideout

Give Oskar some money

Requirement/s:

  • Give 200 gold to Oskar when he asks for it.
Gale +
Karlach +
Wyll +
Shadowheart -
Astarion -
Oskar The Risen RoadZhentarim Basement - In Waukeen's Rest Barn/Basement. Go to the farm area and go through the Doorway blocked by boxes, get through the guard and get to the Hideout

Disguise as a Gith and then talk to Ellyka and say "Relax, it's just a disguise" and then "no you are safe"

Requirement/s:

  • Use Disguise Self Spell as a Githyanki and scare Ellyka
Lae'zel +
Karlach +
Gale +
None Ellyka The Risen Road, Mountain Pass leading to the Creche - Far West area of the Risen Road.

Encounter the Gith Patrol With Lae'zel, Let Lae'zel lead the conversation with Kith'rak Voss

Requirement/s:

  • Requires Lae'zel in the Party.
Lae'zel +
Karlach +
None Kith'rak Voss The Risen Road, Mountain Pass leading to the Creche - Far West area of the Risen Road

The Gith Patrol With Lae'zel leading the conversation, win the Persuasion Check and Lae'zel wins her Deceit Check in the convo with Kith'rak Voss

Requirement/s:

  • After letting Lae'zel lead the conversation. There will be a prompt of a Persuasion Skill check to hide the artifact
  • Lae'zel as a character with her stats has to roll this deception. Either use Enhance Ability or respec her to have more than her default charisma to win her automatic Deception Roll 
Lae'zel +
Gale +
Astarion + 
Shadowheart +
None Kith'rak Voss The Risen Road, Mountain Pass leading to the Creche - Far West area of the Risen Road

The Gith Patrol with Lae'zel leading, Tell Kith'rak Voss you have the Artifact

Requirement/s:

  • Requires Lae'zel in the Party
None Lae'zel -
Shadowheart -
Astarion -
Kith'rak Voss The Risen Road, Mountain Pass leading to the Creche - Far West area of the Risen Road

Gith Patrol Without Lae'zel, convince Kith'rak Voss to leave you peacefully

Requirement/s:

  • If you do not want to fight:
  • You have to pass the first Skill check, an Arcana Check, then a Wisdom check and then a last Charisma Check with a total 4 Skill checks. 1 purely Charisma, 2 Wisdom  based Checks and the first one with multiple pathways. 
Gale + None Kith'rak Voss The Risen Road, Mountain Pass leading to the Creche - Far West area of the Risen Road

 

Goblin Camp (Outdoor Area and Shattered Sanctum)

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location
Smear the Poo on your face.

 

Requirement/s:

  • Requires to pass the Deceit or Nature Check for dialogue to pass.
Shadowheart +
Karlach  +
Lae'zel -
Astarion -
Wyll -
Sentinel Olak

Goblin Camp - The Goblin Guard post in front of the bridge.

Throw Poo on multiple guards, not the Athletics Check

 

Requirement/s:

  • Requires to pass the Deceit or Nature Check for dialogue to pass.
  • This is not the Athletics Check. This dialogue choice requires you to pick up the dog poo and throwing it to multiple guards
Lae'zel +
Astarion +
Wyll +
Karlach  +
None Sentinel Olak

Goblin Camp - The Goblin Guard post in front of the bridge.

Boo Volo during his performance

Requirement/s:

  • Talk to him during his performance and give a really scathing review
Astarion +
Lae'zel +
Karlach - Volo

Goblin Camp - The central party area. Volo will be in the middle of the Camp performing.

With Tracker Grikka tell "I can get info out of the prisoner"

Requirement/s:

  • Nothing special, just tell the dialogue line to Grikka
Astarion +
Lae'zel +
Shadowheart +
Karlach -
Gale -
Wyll -
Tracker Grikka Goblin Camp - In the Humanoird Barbecue pit in front of the entrance towards the Shattered Sanctum.
With Tracker Klagga, convince him to give the Poem. (Not Illithid Powers)

Requirement/s:

  • Simply use any convincing method to get him to hand the documents. 
  • The illithid powers/True soul option does not give Approval however
Shadowheart +
Gale +
None Tracker Klagga Goblin Camp - In the Humanoird Barbecue pit in front of the entrance towards the Shattered Sanctum.
Convince the Owl Bear Cub to start killing the goblins

Requirement/s:

  • Simply Convince the Owlbear either using Animal Handling or with Speak with animals and a Persuasion Skill Check
  • Can only be done during and or after a  round of Chicken Chase
  • Will cause the Cub to go hostile against the entire camp.
Astarion +
Karlach  +
None Owlbear Cub Goblin Camp - In the Chicken Chase arena and surrounding areas.
Convince the Owl Bear Cub to help win Chicken Chase

Requirement/s:

  • Can only be done with Speak with animals and a Persuasion Skill Check
  • Can only be done during a round of Chicken Chase
Shadowheart +
Karlach  +
Gale +
None Owlbear Cub Goblin Camp - In the Chicken Chase arena and surrounding areas.
Use Illithid to force Krolla to give your winnings

Requirement/s:

  • Becomes available after winning a round of Chicken chase and talking to Krolla
Shadowheart +
Karlach  +
Gale +
Astarion +
None Krolla Goblin Camp - In the Chicken Chase arena and surrounding areas.
Ask the Owl Bear to go to your camp

Requirement/s:

  • Pretty Straight forward, ask the owlbear
  • Can only be done after one round of Chicken Chase.
SShadowheart +
Wyll +
Gale +
None Owlbear Cub Goblin Camp - In the Chicken Chase arena and surrounding areas.
Tell the Goblin Child Eight "Sorry for your loss"

Requirement/s:

  • Eight the Goblin Child and his friends will be beating a dead human corpse in the nearby campfire.
Karlach  +
Gale +
Shadowheart +
Astarion -
Lae'zel -
Eight Goblin Camp - To the side of Novice Crusher's Stage where the wall is broken. There would be a small campfire where the goblin Children is hanging out.
Win the first Intimidation Check with Novice Crusher

Requirement/s:

  • None
Shadowheart +
Lae'zel +
Karlach  +
Gale +
Wyll +
None Novice Crusher Goblin Camp - The stage next to the waypoint of the goblin camp.
Convince Novice Crusher to Kiss your foot

Requirement/s:

  • Requires winning the intimidation roll to shake his confidence.
  • After the 1st Intimidation success check, just win one of the many DC check to force him to kiss your foot.
Astarion +
Lae'zel +
Gale +
Wyll +
Shadowheart +
None Novice Crusher Goblin Camp - The stage next to the waypoint of the goblin camp.
Steal the ring by Kissing the foot of Novice Crusher

Requirement/s:

  • Sleight of hand Skill Check
Shadowheart +
Astarion +
Karlach +
None Novice Crusher Goblin Camp - The stage next to the waypoint of the goblin camp.
Say I'd sooner spit at you and double down to start a fight with Novice Crusher

Requirement/s:

  • Starts Combat
Lae'zel +
Gale +
None Novice Crusher Goblin Camp - The stage next to the waypoint of the goblin camp.
Kiss Novice Crusher Foot

Requirement/s:

  • Say I'd sooner spit and then drop down to your knees.
  • Allow you to lick the foot after kissing it.
Shadowheart + Lae'zel -
Gale -
Wyll -
Karlach -
Novice Crusher Goblin Camp - The stage next to the waypoint of the goblin camp.
Lick Novice Crusher Foot

Requirement/s:

  • Say I'd sooner spit and then drop down to your knees.
  • Will Start a fight with Novice's Gang 
Astarion +
Karlach +
Lae'zel -
Shadowheart -
Wyll -
Gale -
Novice Crusher Goblin Camp - The stage next to the waypoint of the goblin camp.
After Beating Crusher in a fight, force him to kiss foot

Requirement/s:

  • Say I'd sooner spit and then drop down to your knees.
Astarion +
Lae'zel +
Shadowheart +
Karlach +
Gale +
None Novice Crusher Goblin Camp - The stage next to the waypoint of the goblin camp.
After Beating Crusher in a fight, try to kill him

Requirement/s:

  • Say I'd sooner spit and then drop down to your knees.
Astarion +
Lae'zel +
Wyll +
Shadowheart +
Karlach - Novice Crusher Goblin Camp - The stage next to the waypoint of the goblin camp.
After Beating Crusher in a fight, Help him up

Requirement/s:

  • Say I'd sooner spit and then drop down to your knees.
Karlach + Lae'zel -
Shadowheart -
Wyll -
Novice Crusher Goblin Camp - The stage next to the waypoint of the goblin camp.
State you want to torture Liam

Requirement/s:

  • Just Choose this option when given the chance in the Dialogue with Spike
Lae'zel +
Astarion +
Wyll -
Karlach -
Gale -
Liam
Torturer Spike
Goblin Camp ,Shattered Sanctum - As you enter, turn right and keep going that direction to meet Liam and Spike
Every instance of Successful Torture on Liam, repeatable.

Requirement/s:

  • You only get approval if your torture method is effective.
  • Ineffective Torture methods like the Stretching choice or insults does not give approval/disapprova
Lae'zel +
Astarion +
Wyll -
Karlach -
Gale -
Liam
Torturer Spike
Goblin Camp ,Shattered Sanctum - As you enter, turn right and keep going that direction to meet Liam and Spike
Tell Liam "Keep Trying...." when he asks to be released

Requirement/s:

  • You need Spike to to have left the room or dead. It is easy to kill speak and not be detected in this part of the Sanctum
  • If Liam is successfully tortured, he will need a health potion to get back.
Shadowheart +
Astarion +
Wyll -
Karlach -
Gale -
Liam
Torturer Spike
Goblin Camp ,Shattered Sanctum - As you enter, turn right and keep going that direction to meet Liam and Spike

When speaking to Minthara and her talking about the prisoner (Liam), say you can be very persuasive

Requirement/s:

  • In order for this dialogue to exist,  you must have not tortured Liam yet.

Shadowheart +

Lae'zel +

Karlach -
Gale -
Minthara Goblin Camp ,Shattered Sanctum - North Eastern part of the Sanctum, Minthara's Room. 

Say "You do not need the Prisoner" and then Win the intelligence roll to obfuscate the location of the Druid Grove to Minthara

Requirement/s:

  • In order for this dialogue to exist,  you must have not tortured Liam yet.
Karlach +
Gale +
Wyll +
None Minthara Goblin Camp ,Shattered Sanctum - North Eastern part of the Sanctum, Minthara's Room.
 

Say "You do not need the Prisoner" and then Win the intelligence roll to obfuscate the location of the Druid Grove to Minthara

Requirement/s:

  • In order for this dialogue to be availaible.: Liam must have been tortured successfully and Or Liam has already escaped.
  • You can torture Liam successfully, Help Liam escape and prevent Spike from telling Minthara the Intel. 

    Just do it in this order;
    1. Talk to Minthara about the Prisoner, get the intelligence Skill check
    2. Torture Liam successfully
    3. Kill Spike before he can tell Minthara the location
    4.  Talk to Minthara
  • If you do the the above method , Minthara will ask about the location of the grove twice.
  • First when you say, Liam was tortured sucessfully.
  • Second when you tell Minthara that Liam escaped.
  • Both instances give the deceit roll which you can farm.
Karlach +
Gale +
Wyll +
?? Minthara Goblin Camp ,Shattered Sanctum - North Eastern part of the Sanctum, Minthara's Room.

Defend Sazza from Minthara's accusation and say "Sazza didn't know"

Requirement/s:

  • Rescue Sazza from the Makeshift prison and escort her back to the Goblin Camp
Karlach +
Astarion +
Lae'zel -
Wyll -
Minthara Goblin Camp ,Shattered Sanctum - North Eastern part of the Sanctum, Minthara's Room.

Participate in the Loviatar Ritual

Requirement/s:

  • In order for this dialogue to be availaible.: Liam must have been tortured successfully and Or Liam has already escaped.
Shadowheart +
Astarion +
Karlach - Abdirak Goblin Camp ,Shattered Sanctum - Abdirak's Room will be inbetween the Spike's Torture room and Volo's Cell.

Inform Roah if you wiped out the Zhenterim Hideout

Requirement/s:

  • If you ever end up killing the entire Zhenatrim Hideout, either due to opening the stolen chest or choosing to not kill Rugan or just wiping them out murder hobo style.
Astarion +
Lae'zel +
Karlach +
?? Roah Moonglow Goblin Camp ,Shattered Sanctum - Trader in he Lower Left/South- West Side of Area.

If you saved Sazza from the prison, tell Minthara "She is too stupid to Understand"

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Lae'zel +
Shadowheart +
Astarion +
Wyll +
?? Sazza 
Minthara
Goblin Camp ,Shattered Sanctum - North Eastern part of the Sanctum, Minthara's Room.

Tell Halsin "I'll deal with this, you get to safety" after rescuing him in the Warg Pens

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Gale +
Karlach +
Shadowheart -
Astarion -
Halsin Goblin Camp ,Shattered Sanctum - Worg Pens, Far eastern door.

Let the True Soul Gut Brand you.

Requirement/s:

  • Don't be marked as enemies of the Absolute
None

Shadowheart -
Astarion -

True Soul Gut Goblin Camp ,Shattered Sanctum -Middle of the Sanctum

Tell the True Soul Gut "All right. I'm ready" after following her to somewhere private.

Requirement/s:

  • Don't be marked as enemies of the Absolute
  • Don't leave the area without seeing if the goblin priestess can heal you.
Karlach + Astarion - True Soul Gut

Goblin Camp ,Shattered Sanctum -South Western part of the Sanctum

Tell the True Soul Gut "Change of plans, I'm going to kill you" after following her to somewhere private.

Requirement/s:

  • Don't be marked as enemies of the Absolute
 Astarion
Shadowheart +
 ??? True Soul Gut Goblin Camp, Shattered Sanctum -South Western part of the Sanctum
 

After saving Halsin use the Rogue option: "Best if I try settling this discreetly - wait here, and you'll have your deaths."

Requirements:

  • Rogue
  • ?
Shadowheart  + ?? Halsin

Goblin Camp, Shattered Sanctum - Worg Pens, Far eastern door.

Evade suspicion from Dror Ragzlin after he questions the dead Illithid

Requirement/s:

  • Don't be marked as enemies of the Absolute

  Shadowheart +Karlach +Gale +
 
 ??
 
 Dror Ragzlin Goblin Camp, Shattered Sanctum - Due North in Sanctum

Convince the Spider in the Shattered Sanctum to eat the Goblins

Requirement/s:

Shadowheart +Gale +   Giant Spider Goblin Camp, Shattered Sanctum - Spider Pit. Where the Prisoner is thrown and or accessed in the locked door behind True Soul Gut

 

Underdark

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location
Tell Boooal You Are Going To Kill Him and Take His Power

 

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Lae'zel +
Astarion +
Shadowheart +
Gale +
?? BOOAL

UnderdarkThe Festering Cove

Succeed the Persuasion When Talking to the Myconid King

 

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Shadowheart +  ?    Underdark - 
Tell the Restless Myconid the truth about the parasite and that you seek safe passage.

 

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Karlach +
Shadowheart + 
Gale +
 ?   Underdark - 

Pick the following option when speaking with Gekh Coal;

  • "Attack him'

Requirement;

  • Don't bring Glut (The Myconid)
Gale +   Gekh Coal Underdark - Beach
Steal the Boots of Speed from Thulla

 

Requirement/s:

  • For a morally questionable actions, this once again shows consistency with Shadowheart's preference for actions that resort to Extortion, Thievery, and Scaming.
Shadowheart +
Astarion +
Karlach - Thulla Underdark - Ebonlake Grotto 
Tell the Restless Myconid that you are a traveler seeking adventure.

 

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Karlach +  ?   Underdark - 
Give the poisoned gnome Thulla antitoxin.

 

Requirement/s:

  • Encounter Thulla, Acquire the antitoxin and save Thulla
Karlach + 
Wyll + 
 ? Thulla Underdark - Ebonlake Grotto 
Take Spaw's side and kill Glut.

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Astarion + ?? Sovereign Glut
Sovereign Spaw
Underdark - Myconid Colony, Sovereign Spaw's area.

Report to Sovereign Spaw about killing Glut.

Requirement/s:

  • Siding with Spaw right away and killing Glut without taking his quest
  • ??

Karlach +

Gale +

 

 None Sovereign Glut
Sovereign Spaw
Underdark - Myconid Colony, Sovereign Spaw's area.

Side with Glut and Kill Sovereign Spaw

Requirement/s:

??

Astarion + Wyll -
Lae'zel -
Sovereign Glut
Sovereign Spaw
Underdark - Myconid Colony, Sovereign Spaw's area.

Do not pick a side between Glut and Sovereign Spaw

Requirement/s:

??

Lae'zel +   Sovereign Glut Underdark - Myconid Colony, Sovereign Spaw's area.
Report details of the event after the Duergar was killed.

 

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Karlach +   Sovereign Spaw Underdark - Myconid Colony,  Sovereign Spaw's area.
Offer to help Baelen Bonecloak.

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Karlach +   Baelen Bonecloak

Underdark - Baelin is trapped in the northwest corner of Underdark, surrounded by Bibberbang. It is closeby to the Myconid Colony. Directly west of it.

Offer to help Baelen Bonecloak for a Price.

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Astarion +   Baelen Bonecloak Underdark - Baelin is trapped in the northwest corner of Underdark, surrounded by Bibberbang. It is closeby the Myconid Colony. Directly west of it.
Refuse to help Baelen Bonecloak.

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Astarion + Wyll - Baelen Bonecloak Underdark - Baelin is trapped in the northwest corner of Underdark, surrounded by Bibberbang.  It is closeby the Myconid Colony. Directly west of it.

 

 

 Grymforge

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location
Push Corsair Greymon into the water.

Requirement/s:

  • ??

Astarion +

Lae'zel +

??? Corsair Greymon Grymforge - When you set sail for the Grymforge, you will encounter the Corsair in a Cutscene.
Ask Ward Magmar how you can get a slave of your own
  •  ??

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Astarion + ??? Ward Magmar Grymforge -
Tell Ward Magmar that he disgusts you

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Karlach  + 
Gale +
Astarion 

Ward Magmar Grymforge -

Agree with Astarion that you don't need the lantern / to save Nere, 'we cant turn back now' when trying to open the gate to moonrise towers

Requirement/s:

  • ??
Astarion + ??? True Soul Nere Grymforge -

Tell the Deep Gnomes that you will see what you can do

Requirement/s:

  • Pass Perception check (10) to evesdrop on the conversation between the Deep Gnomes
  • Convince them that you're here to help

Karlach +

Gale +

???

Lunkbug

Apprentice Laridda

Grymforge - Dig Site
If you choose to free him from the cave in, tell true soul Nere to 'finish the slaves' for the absolute.

Requirement/s:

  • Get Nere out of the Cave in alive
  • ??
Astarion + ??? True Soul Nere Grymforge - Dig Site
If you choose to free him from the cave in, tell true soul Nere "Stop. No more innocents will die today, Nere."

Requirement/s:

  • Get Nere out of the cave in alive
  • ??

Karlach +

Gale +

Astarion - True Soul Nere Grymforge - Dig Site
After freeing Nere side with Brithvar and the rebels against him.

Requirement/s:

  • Get Nere out of the cave in alive
  • ??
??? Karlach - True Soul Nere Grymforge - Dig Site
After defeating Nere together with Elder Brithvar persuade him to leave the Gnomes behind.

Requirement/s:

  • Take the deal with Elder Brithvar (unclear if absolutely necessary)
  • Do not side with Nere against the mercenaries
  • Pass the Persuation Check (10)

Karlach +

Shadowheart +

Gale +

Astarion - Elder Brithvar Grymforge - Dig Site
Tell Skickpit to Take the Lift to the Surface After Killing his Masters

 

Requirement/s:

  • Talk to Stickpick and tell him that you are here to help (not sure if necessary)
  • Kill Ward Magmar and Ward Pistle

Lae'zel +

Astarion +

 ??? Skickpit Grymforge -
Tell Skickpit to Hide until things have calmed down

Requirement/s:

  • Talk to Stickpick and tell him that you are here to help (not sure if necessary)
  • Kill Ward Magmar and Ward Pistle

Karlach +

Gale +

 

 ??? Skickpit Grymforge -
Persuade the Deep Rothe in attacking its Master
  • Get past the rubble (The Adamantine Forge)

Requirement/s:

  • Agree to help Herdmaster Skarjall with the Deep Rothe

Lae'zel +

Shadowheart +

Karlach +

Gale +

??? Deep Rothe Grymforge -
Persuade the Deep Rothe to calm down so the Masters don't destroy her herd.
  • Get past the rubble (The Adamantine Forge)

Requirement/s:

  • Agree to help Herdmaster Skarjall with the Deep Rothe
  • ??

Shadowheart +

Karlach - Deep Rothe Grymforge -

Bow your head in respect. 

Requirement/s:

  • Speak to Brathwen and Viss and roll for perception to inspect the corpses. Decieve them and tell them you will take it from there and they are wanted with the others. 

Karlach +

Astarion - Brathwen Grymforge - Abandoned Refuge

When you meet Morghal and Orgarth in the Grymforge, ask "Did you say you keep slaves here?" then say "Not a problem in the slightest"

Requirement/s:

  • Insert yourself into the conversation of Morghal and Orgarth
Lae'zel +   None Morghal and Orgarth Grymforge - 

 

Mountain Pass (Rosymorn Monastery and Crèche Y'llek)

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub-Location

Let Lae'zel answer when trying to enter the Githyanki Créche.

Requirement/s:

Lae'zel + Shadowheart - Guards (Automatic Conversation) Crèche Y'llek  - Entrance

Persuade Sa'Varsh Kethk to leave the boy alone.

Requirement/s:

  • Suceed Persuation Check (21)
Shadowheart + N/A Sa'varsh Kethk Crèche Y'llek - Training Room

Tell Sa'Varsh Keth you'll fight the boy and proceed to kill him.

Requirement/s:

-

Astarion + Shadowheart - Sa'varsh Kethk Crèche Y'llek - Training Room

Persuade Youth Varrl to give you the book.

Requirement/s:

  • Suceed Persuation Check
  • After Suceeding, you can talk to Lae'zel about it.
Lae'zel + N/A Youth Varrl Crèche Y'llek - Training Room

When speaking to Ghustil Stornugoss for the first time, allow Lae'zel to speak on your behalf.

Requirement/s:

  • Have Lae'zel in your party
Lae'zel + N/A Ghustil Storngoss Crèche Y'llek -

Let Lae'zel go first into the zaith'isk.

Requirement/s:

  • Have Lae'zel in your party
Lae'zel + N/A Ghustil Storngoss Crèche Y'llek - Infirmary

When interacting with the zai'thisk, insist on going before Lae'zel. Then, say, "You would still be hunting for this place without my guidance."

Requirement/s:

  • Have Lae'zel in your party
 Lae'zel +    Ghustil Storngoss Crèche Y'llek - Infirmary

Persuade Lae'zel to get out of the zaith'isk.

Requirement/s:

  • Let Lae'zel go first into the machine
  • Pass Perseption Check and understand that the zaith'isk kills instead of heals
  • Pass Persuation Check (21) (Depends on your current approval. Some people get (30) Difficulty check)

Shadowheart +

Astarion +

N/A Ghustil Storngoss Crèche Y'llek - Infirmary

Convince Varsh Ko'kuu to give you the egg and tell him you'll find another Crèche that is more forgiving.

Requirement/s:

  • Pass Persuasion Check
Lae’zel +
Gale +
Astarion - Varsh Ko'kuu Crèche Y'llek - Hatchery

Convince Varsh Ko'kuu to give you the egg and tell him you'll raise it as your own or take it to another Nursery.

Requirement/s:

  • Pass Insight Check
  • Pass 2x Persuasion Check (16)
Lae’zel + Astarion - Varsh Ko'kuu Crèche Y'llek - Hatchery

Convince Varsh Ko'kuu to give you the egg and tell him you'll make the best omelette. (This will start a fight)

Requirement/s:

  • Pass Persuasion Check
Astarion + Karlach -
Shadowheart -
Varsh Ko'kuu Crèche Y'llek - Hatchery

Show Kith'rak Therezzyn the artifact.

Requirement/s:

Lae'zel +

Astarion -

Shadowheart -

Kith'rak Therezzyn Crèche Y'llek - Captain's Quarters

Tell Kith'rak Therezzyn you have the artifact but say "No". (This will trigger a fight)

Requirement/s:

Astarion +

Shadowheart +

?

Kith'rak Therezzyn Crèche Y'llek- Captain's Quarters

Ask inquisitor Ch'r'ai W'wargaz why he knows so much about you.

Requirement/s:

Astarion + N/A Ch'r'ai W'wargaz Crèche Y'llek - Inquisitorial Rooms

Do not kneel before Vlaakith.

Requirement/s:

N/A Lae'zel - Vlaakith Crèche Y'llek - Inquisitorial Rooms

Kneel before Vlaakith.

Requirement/s:

Lae'zel +   Vlaakith Crèche Y'llek - Inquisitorial Rooms

Enter the artifact.

Requirement/s:

Lae'zel + Shadowheart - Vlaakith Crèche Y'llek - Inquisitorial Rooms

 

Events/Camp Events/Companion Events and Dialogue Act 1

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location

During the First Long Rest, When Gale talks to himself and Say "Go to Hell" respond with "And good evening to you too."

 

Requirement/s:

  • First Long Rest
  • Talk to Gale
Gale + None Gale First Long Rest

Camp 

Agree with Lae'zel that the Gith Library Knowledge is Valuable

 

Requirement/s:

  • Available with Companion as soon as you recruit them.
  • Talk to Lae'zel about the value of the Knowledge the Gith on the tadpole and Agree with her that the knowledge the Githyanki Library possess is valuable
Lae'zel + None Lae'zel Early Conversations with Companion

Anywhere with Lae'zel  - In party or Camp

While talking to Lae'zel about the Tadpole, agree with here you will all be cured

 

Requirement/s:

  • Available with Companion as soon as you recruit them.
Lae'zel + None Lae'zel Early Conversation with Companion

Anywhere with Lae'zel  - In party or Camp

While talking to Lae'zel about the Tadpole, choose to panic

 

Requirement/s:

  • Available with Companion as soon as you recruit them.
None Lae'zel - Lae'zel Early Conversation with Companion

Anywhere with Lae'zel  - In party or Camp

When asking about Gale's past, attempt and succeed in the Wisdom roll of reading his mind.

 

Requirement/s:

  • Available with Companion as soon as you recruit them.
  • Ask Gale about his past.
None Gale -  Gale Early Conversation with Companion

Anywhere with Lae'zel  - In party or Camp

When encountering a Soul Coin with Karlach in the Party, agree with her to use it.

 

Requirement/s:

  • Requires Karlach in the Party
  • Requires a Soul Coin found or in the Inventory.
Karlach + None Karlach Karlach - In Party when encountering a Soul Coin

When Astarion asks about how you want to die, Say your preferred method (Knife, Poison, Decapitation)

 

Requirement/s:

  • Prompted by Astarion.
Astarion + None Astarion Early Conversation with Companion

Astarion - In party and or Camp

When Astarion asks about how you want to die, respond with "ill spill your guts"

 

Requirement/s:

  • Prompted by Astarion.
  Astarion - Astarion Early Conversation with Companion

Astarion - In party and or Camp

When Astarion asks about how you want to die, respond with "ill spill your guts" and then "If I die, I will take you with me"

 

Requirement/s:

  • Prompted by Astarion.
Astarion +    Astarion Early Conversation with Companion

Astarion - In party and or Camp

After finding out he is a vampire, when he asks do you to trust him say "I do believe you"

Requirement/s:

  • After getting out of the Druids Grove and encountering the blood drained/exsanguinated boar. The next Long rest will activate Astarion's drinking event.
  • Choose to trust/ react positively to  Astarion when he is revealed to be a vampire to have this dialouge option to be open.
Astarion +

Gale -
Wyll -

Astarion

Vampire Reveal Camp Event 



Camp
- A Long Rest event after finding the drained boar.

After finding out he is a vampire, Allow him to drink

Requirement/s:

  • After getting out of the Druids Grove and encountering the blood drained/exsanguinated boar. The next Long rest will activate Astarion's drinking event.
  • Choose to trust/ react positively to  Astarion when he is revealed to be a vampire to have this dialouge option to be open.
Astarion + None Astarion

Vampire Reveal Camp Event 

Camp - A Long Rest event after finding the drained boar.

In the morning after the vampire reveal. Defend Astarion to the suspicions of the party.

Requirement/s:

  • Choose to trust/ react positively to  Astarion when he is revealed to be a vampire to have this dialouge option to be open.
Astarion + Wyll (-1) Astarion

Vampire Reveal Camp Event 

Camp - The day after the Vampire Reveal Scene

With Wyll when meeting Karlach, tell Wyll to kill Karlach

Requirement/s:

  • Will activate if you first meet Karlach with Wyll in the party.
  • This encounter will happen in Camp if you recruit Karlach without Wyll in the party.
Wyll + None Karlach

Risen Road - Far Right Side/South West of the Area by the river. Indicated by Wyll's Quest. 

or

Camp - Long Rest event with Karlach and Wyl

 

Wyll when meeting Karlach, tell Wyll Karlach is no danger

Requirement/s:

  • Will activate if you first meet Karlach with Wyll in the party.
  • This encounter will happen in Camp if you recruit Karlach without Wyll in the party. The dialogue will proc if Karlach and Wyll is recruited and long rest for the evening
  • It is recomended to do this scene in Camp as every Companion will like it if you defend Karlach. Including Wyll and Karlach
Wyll +
Shadowheart   +
Gale +
Lae'zel  +
Astarion  +
Karlach +
None Karlach

Risen Road - Far Right Side/South West of the Area by the river. Indicated by Wyll's Quest. 

or

Camp - Long Rest event with Karlach and Wyl

Flirt with Mizora as a first reaction.

Requirement/s:

  • Has recruited Karlach.
  • Convinced Wyll not to kill Karlach
  • Do a long rest after doing these two requirements.
  • This is part of the first Dialogue with Mizora
None Wyll -
Karlach -
Mizora 
Karlach
Wyll
 

Mizora's First Camp Appearance Event

Camp - Long Rest event after recruiting Karlach with Wyll in the Camp

Say "You better not lay a finger on Karlach" to Mizora.

Requirement/s:

  • Has recruited Karlach.
  • Convinced Wyll not to kill Karlach
  • Do a long rest after doing these two requirements.
  • Part of the Dialouge when trying to figure out what the party will do with Karlach and Mizora
Shadowheart +
Wyll +
Karlach +
Gale +
Lae'zel  +
None Mizora  

Mizora's First Camp Appearance Event

Camp - Long Rest event after recruiting Karlach with Wyll in the Camp

Say "If we kill Karlach now, will we get rid of you?" to Mizora

Requirement/s:

  • Has recruited Karlach.
  • Convinced Wyll not to kill Karlach
  • Do a long rest after doing these two requirements.
  • Part of the Dialouge when trying to figure out what the party will do with Karlach and Mizora
None Shadowheart -
Wyll -
Karlach -
Gale -
Lae'zel -
Mizora

Mizora's First Camp Appearance Event

Camp - Long Rest event after recruiting Karlach with Wyll in the Camp

 Say "I've heard enough, you are not leaving this place alive" to Mizora

Requirement/s:

  • Has recruited Karlach.
  • Convinced Wyll not to kill Karlach
  • Do a long rest after doing these two requirements.
  • Part of the Dialouge when trying to figure out what the party will do with Karlach and Mizora
Shadowheart +
Astarion  +
Karlach +
Gale +
Lae'zel  +
None  Mizora

Mizora's First Camp Appearance Event

Camp - Long Rest event after recruiting Karlach with Wyll in the Camp

Talking to Wyll after Mizora disappears, Say "You Should get out of this Pact"

Requirement/s:

  • When talking to Wyll after he becomes a devil
  • This specific choice opens a unique dialogue tree with Wyll in this Dialogue Event.
Wyll + None Wyll

 

Talking to Wyll after Mizora's Visit/Wyll's transformation.

Camp
 /In Party - Talk to Wyll after his transformation.

Talking to Wyll after Mizora disappears, Say "We can beat her,"

Requirement/s:

  • When talking to Wyll after he becomes a devil
  • This specific choice opens a unique dialogue tree with Wyll in this Dialogue Event.
  • First choose the dialogue "You Should get out of this Pact". 
  • Eventually you will get the dialogue line "We can beat her,"
Wyll +  None Wyll

Talking to Wyll after Mizora's Visit/Wyll's transformation.

Camp
 /
In Party - Talk to Wyll after his transformation.

Talking to Wyll after Mizora disappears, Say "How the hells did you get involved?"

Requirement/s:

  • When talking to Wyll after he becomes a devil
  • A new question becomes available after his transformation.
Wyll +  None Wyll

Talking to Wyll after Mizora's Visit/Wyll's transformation.

Camp
 /
In Party - Talk to Wyll after his transformation.

Talking to Wyll after Mizora disappears, Say "How does it feel to be a devil?"

Requirement/s:

  • When talking to Wyll after he becomes a devil
  • A new question becomes available after his transformation.
 Wyll + none Wyll

Talking to Wyll after Mizora's Visit/Wyll's transformation.

Camp
 /
In Party - Talk to Wyll after his transformation.

Talking to Wyll after Mizora disappears,

After saying "How does it feel to be a devil?",

say "The blade of frontiers, no more no less" or "Quite the Handsome Devil"

Requirement/s:

  • When talking to Wyll after he becomes a devil
  • A new question becomes available after his transformation.
  • Ask "How does it feel to be a devil?""
  • Answer him when he asks what do you see with:
  • "The blade of frontiers, no more no less" or
  • "Quite the Handsome Devil"
  Wyll +  none  Wyll Talking to Wyll after Mizora's Visit/Wyll's transformation.

Camp
 /
In Party - Talk to Wyll after his transformation.
After fiinding out about Shadowheart's Shar Worship

,Say "I don't care who you worship"

Requirement/s:

  • Will trigger when you reach Medium/Good approval from Shadowheart.
  • Talk to Shadowheart about the Strange magic from her hand.
  • When the Persuasion Roll shows up, win it to convince Shadowheart to reveal her Shar Worship.
  • Choose the Dialog "I don't care who you worship" to gain approval
Shadowheart
Karlach+
None Shadowheart

Strange Magic Event with Shadowheart

Camp /In Party 

When the strange Magic happens to Shadowheart's hand, choose Turn a blind eye and Ignore the Subject

Requirement/s:

  • Will trigger when you reach Medium/Good approval from Shadowheart.
  • Talk to Shadowheart about the Strange magic from her hand.
Shadowheart+ 
Karlach+
 None Shadowheart

Strange Magic Event with Shadowheart

Camp /In Party 

Ask Shadowheart about Shar and assure her with persuation that you have no problems with it

Requirement/s:

  • Requires to know that Shadowheart is a Shar Worshipper to be available.
  • Win either Persuasion Check
  • One Persuasion Check will have a lower DC depending on how high your approval is.
Shadowheart+  ?? Shadowheart

Asking Shadowheart about her worship of Shar

Camp /In Party 

Ask Shadowheart about her missing memories, ask her about what flower she likes

Requirement/s:

  • Requires to know that Shadowheart is a Shar Worshipper to be available.
  • Romance Trigger for Shadowheart
  • Usually unlocks around the same Approval Level you find out she is a Shar Worshipper.
Shadowheart+  ??  Shadowheart

Asking Shadowheart about her worship of Shar

Camp /In Party 

When asking Shadowheart about Shar, follow the dialogue recommended below for maximum approval gain

Requirement/s:

  • Requires to know that Shadowheart is a Shar Worshipper to be available.
  • MULTIPLE INSTANCES OF APPROVAL
  • First win the Persuasion Roll
  • Then Choose "Remind Me" or "She doesn't sound appealing, going by her titles" 
  • After this she will explain Shar.
  • Important choices is to either say "I won't cast judgements on your beliefs" or "I'd be lying if I said it didn't sound convincing......"
Shadowheart+  ??  Shadowheart

Asking Shadowheart about her worship of Shar

Camp /In Party 

Ask Shadowheart about Shar, follow the long series of correct Dialogue Options above^.

And then in the last dialogue line , Choose Call her faith evil

Requirement/s:

  • Requires to know that Shadowheart is a Shar Worshipper to be available.
Lae'zel  +   Shadowheart-   Shadowheart

Asking Shadowheart about her worship of Shar

Camp /In Party 

When Astarion asks about whose blood will Tav/Durge drink

Answer the name of any companion or Astarion

Requirement/s:

  • Astarion at around 50%  approval
 Astarion  + ?? Astarion

Astarion asks about whose blood will Tav/Durge drink among the Companions.

Camp /In Party 

When Astarion asks about whose blood will Tav/Durge drink

Refuse to Answer the question

Requirement/s:

  • Astarion at around  50%  approval
?? Astarion -  Astarion

Astarion asks about whose blood will Tav/Durge drink among the Companions.

Camp /In Party 

Appreciate Shadowhear when she opens up about her ambitions.

Requirement/s:

  • Requires Very Good/ 65%-75% Shadowheart Approval
Shadowheart+ None Shadowheart

Shadowheart talks about her dreams of becoming a Dark Justiciar

Camp /In Party 

Insult Shadowheart when she opens up about her ambitions.

Requirement/s:

  • Requires Very Good/ 65%-75% Shadowheart Approval
None Shadowheart-  Shadowheart

Shadowheart talks about her dreams of becoming a Dark Justiciar

Camp /In Party 

Appreciate Shadowheart when she opens up about her memories.

Requirement/s:

  • Requires Very Good/ 65%-75% Shadowheart Approval
Shadowheart+  None Shadowheart

Shadowheart Shows her Flashback

Camp /In Party 

Question Shadowheart when she opens up about her memories.

Requirement/s:

  • Requires Very Good/ 65%-75% Shadowheart Approval
None Shadowheart-  Shadowheart

Shadowheart Shows her Flashback

Camp /In Party 

Gale Special Scenes/ Massive Approval

Requirement/s:

  • Completing any of the quests mentioned below with Gale in the party will result in a massive boost of Approval
  • Gale will also have a special Dialogue after the quest.
  • Complete Save Arabella with Arabella Alive
  • Complete Investigate the Beach with Mirkon Alive
  • Stand between Arka's Crossbow and Sazza. Then convince Arka not to kill Sazza
Gale + None Gale Gale in the Party while 
Say, "That's very gratifying to hear"  when Gale Praises your heroic Deeds

Requirement/s:

  • Requires +50%/Medium Gale Approval
Gale + None Gale  

Gale starts asking for Magical Items to eat.

Camp /In Party 

Agree to his request of items

Requirement/s:

  • Requires +50%/Medium Gale Approval
Gale + None Gale

Gale starts asking for Magical Items to eat.

Camp /In Party 

Accuse Gale of Loot Hoarding

Requirement/s:

  • Requires +50%/Medium Gale Approval
None Gale - Gale

Gale starts asking for Magical Items to eat.

Camp /In Party 

Use the tadpole on Gale's mind when he refuses to answer why he eats magical items and get caught

Requirement/s:

  • Gale will threaten to leave camp if you fail this roll.
  • It is a very high Wisdom Roll.
None Gale - Gale

Gale starts asking for Magical Items to eat.

Camp /In Party 

Give Gale a Magical Item when he asks for it.

Requirement/s:

  • Repeated three times
Gale + None Gale

Gale starts asking for Magical Items to eat.

Camp /In Party 

When Gale finally reveals his past, choose to accept him even with all the risks

Requirement/s:

  • Given Gale Magical Items three times
  • Have reached +65% Gale Approval
Gale + None Gale

Gale starts asking for Magical Items to eat.

Camp /In Party 

Refuse Raphael's Deal

Requirement/s:

  • Straightforward refuse his offer.
Karlach +
Astarion + 
Lae'zel +
Shadowheart +
Wyll +
None Raphael

Raphael Event - Multiple Locations on Act 1

Will Show up in your camp if you miss all the locations and head straight to the Mountain Pass.

Say "Ill think about it" to Raphael's Deal

Requirement/s:

Lae'zel +
Shadowheart +Gale +
None Raphael

Raphael Event - Multiple Locations on Act 1

Will Show up in your camp if you miss all the locations and head straight to the Mountain Pass.

Say Yes to Raphael's Deal

Requirement/s:

None Astarion -
Karlach -
Wyll -
Raphael

Raphael Event - Multiple Locations on Act 1

Will Show up in your camp if you miss all the locations and head straight to the Mountain Pass.

Say "Then Fix it or die by my hand" to Raphael's Offer

Requirement/s:

Karlach +
Astarion + 
Lae'zel +
Gale +
Wyll +
None Raphael

Raphael Event - Multiple Locations on Act 1

Will Show up in your camp if you miss all the locations and head straight to the Mountain Pass.

Talking to Karlach after encountering Raphael, say "I'd enjoy watching that" when she describes destroying Raphael.

Requirement/s:

  • Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer
Karlach + None  

Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer

In Camp or In party

Talking to Astarion after encountering Raphael, say "We are not his playthings"

Requirement/s:

  • Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer
Astarion + None  

Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer

In Camp or In party

Talking to Astarion after encountering Raphael, say "You may not know how to Outfox him but I do"

Requirement/s:

  • Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer
None Astarion -  

Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer

In Camp or In party

Talking to Wyll after encountering Raphael, say "Spare me parable, I have no intentions of taking the Deal"

Requirement/s:

  • Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer
Wyll + None  

Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer

In Camp or In party

Talking to Wyll after encountering Raphael, consider Raphael's deal

Requirement/s:

  • Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer
None Wyll -  

Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer

In Camp or In party

Talking to Wyll after encountering Raphael, ask him for his opinion and then bring up Mizora

Requirement/s:

  • Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer
None Wyll -   

Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer

In Camp or In party

Talking to Shadowheart after encountering Raphael,

say "never trust the devil" and then say "You won't change my mind, we shouldn't trust Raphael"

Requirement/s:

  • Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer
Karlach 
Shadowheart +
None  

Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer

In Camp or In party

Talking to Shadowheart after encountering Raphael,

say "He might be of Help", keep defending Raphael and then choose "maybe raphael could be a friend"

Requirement/s:

  • Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer
None

Karlach 
Shadowheart -

 

Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer

In Camp or In party

Talking to Lae'zel after encountering Raphael, say "he is rather impressive" or "respect him...."

Requirement/s:

  • Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer
None Lae'zel -  

Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer

In Camp or In party

Talking to Gale after encountering Raphael, say "And how do you propose we beat a devil in his own game"

Requirement/s:

  • Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer
Gale + None  

Talk to the Companions after Raphael's Offer

In Camp or In party

Say "If you have my back, I have yours" when Astarion talks about Cazador.

Requirement/s:

Astarion + None  

Astarion talks about Cazador 

Camp - In party

Describe Astarion as Prompted then either say "You are beautiful" or "Insert Companion name is better looking"

Requirement/s:

Astarion + None   Astarion talks about the Mirror and not seeing his face. 

Camp - In party

Say to Wyll after rescuing Florick, "The Choice is clear, we must rescue Duke Ravengaurd"

Requirement/s:

  • Becomes available after rescuing Counsellor Florrick from the Fire in Waukeen's Rest.
  • Just Talk to Wyll anywhere right after.
 Wyll + None Wyll

Wyll is revealed to be Duke Ravenguard's Son.

Camp - In party

Tell Astarion "Thank you, I'll rest better for that" after he says he will keep watch.

Requirement/s:

  • At first camp talk to companions in this order Lae'zel-Astarion-Shadowheart
Astarion +    

Astarion talking about resting in the dirt being a little novel

Camp

Tell Shadowheart that we shouldn't abandon all caution.

Requirements/s:

  • At first camp talk to companions in this order Lae'zel-Astarion-Shadowheart
Astarion +    

Shadowheart when talking about next steps

Camp

Tell Shadowheart that you agree on needing to rapidly find a healer.

Requirement/s:

  • At first camp talk to companions in this order Lae'zel-Astarion-Shadowheart
Shadowheart +
Gale +
Lae'zel -  

Shadowheart when talking about next steps

Camp

During the Night of the 1st Tadpole Dream, convince Lae'zel to stand down

Requirement/s:

  • Use the Illithid Persuasion power enough times to trigger the dream. 
  • I don't have a clear estimate but if I had to guess it is around the 3-7 times using it that will trigger the dream
  • You can only use the illithid persuasion once per day, so long rest often before an oppurtunity arise to use the power as you might lose the chance
  • After using it enough the scene of the entire party extremely tired and feverish will play and you can convince Lae'zel
  • Any skill check or method that works with you not dead is great.
Wyll 
Gale + 
Lae'zel  +
Shadowheart +
   

1st Tadpole Dream,

Camp - Long Rest

Talking to Lae'zel after the 1st tadpole dream, say we should reject the tadpole

Requirement/s:

  • During the Morning after the tadpole dream, simply say this to Lae'zel right after 
Lae'zel  +    

The morning after the 1st Tadpole Dream,

Camp - Long Rest

During the extremely hostile confrontation between Lae'zel and Shadowheart, Win the Persuasion Check during the dagger scene

Requirement/s:

  • Will usually happen after the Absolute cutscene in the Bridge or Mountain Pass Route that are both near the Goblin Camp. As this will reveal the significance of the Artifact
  • Win the Persuasion Check during the dagger scene. 
  • This dialogue is the only way to prevent any companions to not die.
Lae'zel  +
Wyll 
Gale +

   

The Artifact confrontation between Lae'zel and Shadowheart

Camp - Long Rest

During the extremely hostile confrontation between Lae'zel and Shadowheart, Let Lae'zel Die

Requirement/s:

  • Will usually happen after the Absolute cutscene in the Bridge or Mountain Pass Route that are both near the Goblin Camp. As this will reveal the significance of the Artifact
  • Kill the designated companion
  Lae'zel -
Wyll -
Gale -
 

The Artifact confrontation between Lae'zel and Shadowheart

Camp - Long Rest

During the extremely hostile confrontation between Lae'zel and Shadowheart, Kill Shadowheart

Requirement/s:

  • Will usually happen after the Absolute cutscene in the Bridge or Mountain Pass Route that are both near the Goblin Camp. As this will reveal the significance of the Artifact
  • Kill the designated companion
Lae'zel  + Gale -  

The Artifact confrontation between Lae'zel and Shadowheart

Camp - Long Rest

During the Owlbear Cub First Appearance in Camp, Feed the Cub

Requirement/s:

  • Different Companions have different dialogue lines.
  • One of the few times Astarion is actually slightly nice.
Shadowheart +
Wyl+
Gale +
Astarion +
Karlach +
  Owlbear Cub

Owlbear Cub first appearance

Camp - Long Rest

During the Owlbear Cub later Appearance in Camp, Pet the Cub

Requirement/s:

  • Pet the Cub

Shadowheart 
Astarion + 
Karlach +

Wyll +

 

   

Owlbear Cub appearance

Camp - Long Rest

Pet Scratch

Requirement/s:

  • Pet Scratch
  • Requires Scratch to go to camp.
  • Tell Scratch when you find him in the Forest to go to your camp if his friend do not wake up.
  • One of the few good deeds that Astarion actually likes
Shadowheart (+1)
Wyll (+1)
Karlach (+1)
  Scratch

Pet Scratch

Camp - Long Rest

Convince Shadowheart to use the Tadpole's Powers

Requirement/s:

  • Requires the Player to consume a Tadpole
  • Consuming a tadpole requires to have done the 1st Tadpole dream
  • Simply win the Persuasion Check with Shadowheart to start using the Tadpoles
Shadowheart +    Shadowheart  Camp or In party

Astarion will be seen reading the Necromancy of Thay after acquiring it. React by suggesting to give it to Gale or state "Stop Reading It"

Requirement/s:

  • Give the Necromancy of Thay to Astarion
  Astarion -   Camp or In party

 

Ruined Battlefield​

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location

Release Dolly Dolly Dolly from the Moonlantern.

Requirements/Details:

  • Defeat Kar'niss
  • Loot the Moonlantern from Kar'niss' body
Karlach + Astarion - Dolly Dolly Dolly Middle of Ruined Battlefield - When you try to find a way to protect yourself from the shadows, you'll come across the drider Kar'niss. Kill him and his crew and then loot the Moonlantern from his body to talk to Dolly Dolly Dolly, the pixie trapped inside.

Keeping Dolly Dolly Dolly in the Moonlantern.

Requirements/Details:

  • Defeat Kar'niss
  • Loot the Moonlantern from Kar'niss' body
Astarion +    Dolly Dolly Dolly  Middle of Ruined Battlefield - When you try to find a way to protect yourself from the shadows, you'll come across the drider Kar'niss. Kill him and his crew and then loot the Moonlantern from his body to talk to Dolly Dolly Dolly, the pixie trapped inside.

Play hide and seek with Oliver

Requirements/Details:

Karlach +
Shadowheart + 
Wyll +

N/A Oliver House in Deep Shadows in the Ruined Battlefield - When you find Oliver near his ruined house, agree to play a game of hide and seek.

Play another round of hide and seek with Oliver

Requirements/Details:

  • Interact with Oliver in the Ruined Battlefield
  • Win against Oliver on the first round of hide and seek
Karlach +
Shadowheart + 
Wyll +
N/A Oliver House in Deep Shadows in the Ruined Battlefield - When you find Oliver near his ruined house and play hide and seek, win against him in the first round, and then agree to play another round.

Get caught by Oliver's "family"

Requirements/Details:

  • Interact with Oliver in the Ruined Battlefield
  • Win against Oliver on the first round of hide and seek
  • Agree to play another round of hide and seek
  • Defeat Oliver's family in battle
N/A Astarion - Oliver House in Deep Shadows in the Ruined Battlefield - When you agree to play another round of hide and seek against Oliver, get caught by his "family" and defeat them in battle. Talk to Oliver afterward.

Do not get caught by Oliver's "family"

Requirements/Details:

  • Interact with Oliver in the Ruined Battlefield
  • Win against Oliver on the first round of hide and seek
  • Agree to play another round of hide and seek
  • Defeat Oliver's family in battle
Astarion +

Lae'zel +
N/A Oliver Ruined Battlefield - House in Deep Shadows close to the waypoint

When trying to convince Oliver to rejoin with Thaniel, tell Halsin to talk to him.

Requirements/Details:

  • Talk to Oliver after playing two rounds of hide and seek with him at the Ruined Battlefield and defeat him
Halsin + N/A Oliver Ruined Battlefield - House in Deep Shadows close to the waypoint

Convince Oliver to rejoin with Thaniel.

Requirements/Details:

  • Talk to Oliver after playing two rounds of hide and seek with him at the Ruined Battlefield and defeat him
Halsin + N/A Oliver Ruined Battlefield - House in Deep Shadows close to the waypoint

After retrieving Madeline's Ledger from the Waning Moon and giving it to He Who Was, pick the following dialogue choices;

  • "Anything? Then hurt yourself as Ben and Marc did - stab yourself"
  • "Start stabbing and don't stop until I say so"
  • "Keep going"

Requirements/Details:

  • Don't attack He Who Was
  • Pass the Perception Check at the Waning Moon distillery to pick up Madeline's Ledger
Astarion +   He Who Was & Madeline Shadow Cursed Lands - North East of the Ruined Battlefield Waypoint

In meeting the Harpers, when Lassandra asks “who’s there?!”, choosing the druid option "Peace - I am a druid"

 

Requirements/Details:

  • Don't attack He Who Was
  Astarion - Lassandra Ruined Battlefield - 

In meeting the Harpers, when Lassandra asks “who’s there?!”, choosing the bard option "A nightmare in the dark"

 

Requirements/Details:

  • Don't attack He Who Was
Astarion +   Lassandra Ruined Battlefield - 

In meeting the Harpers, when Lassandra asks “who’s there?!”, choosing the bard option "I find the best introductions are made while sitting around a fire, perhaps with drinks?"

 

Requirements/Details:

  • Don't attack He Who Was
Karlach +
Wyll +
Astarion - Lassandra Ruined Battlefield - 

In meeting the Harpers, when Yonas becomes a zombie, choose "Run", gives Astarion approval and Gale disapproval

 

Requirements/Details:

  • Don't attack He Who Was
Astarion +

Gale - Lassandra Ruined Battlefield - 

When you encounter Hyena and the Goblin in the Ruined Battlefield , convince the Hyena to run away

 

Requirements/Details:

  • Has multiple skill checks
  • Can be Animal Handling without Speak to Animals
Karlach +
Astarion +
 n/a  Warrior Gronag, Hyena Ruined Battlefield - True Soul Gronak's Camp near the road connecting the Mountain pass to the Ruined Battlefield

 

Last Light Inn

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location
Tell Jaheira everything about the Artefact

Requirements/ Details:

Karlach + N/A Jaheira Bridge to Last Light Inn - You'll be stopped by Jaheira who interrogates you before entering the inn. You'll have the option to show her the artefact when she asks how you aren't enthralled despite having a tadpole. Afterward, choose to tell her everything you know about the artefact.
First meeting with Jaheira:
When she asks why you have come to Last Light Inn, telling her "I'm here on holiday"

Requirements/ Details:

  • Arrive at the Last Light Inn
Astarion + N/A Jaheira Bridge to Last Light Inn

Shuffle the lanceboard in the game between Mol and Raphael

Requirements/Details:

Astarion +
Karlach 
Gale +

N/A Raphael
Mol
First floor of Last Light Inn - You'll find Mol pretending to be a beginner in a lanceboard game against Raphael, perform a successful Sleight of Hand check to shuffle the board in favor of Mol.

Drink the wine prepared by Jaheira

Requirements/Details:

Karlach + Astarion -
Shadowheart -
Jaheira First floor of Last Light Inn - Jaheira had invited you for a drink when you entered the area. She prepared wine for you which, if you perform a successful Medicine check, you'll discover is laced with a truth herb. You can either drink it anyway or refuse to.

Decline the wine prepared by Jaheira

Requirements/Details:

Astarion
 +
Gale +

Shadowheart +
Lae'zel +

?? Jaheira  Last Light Inn - First Flor

Tell His Majesty (the cat) that you came to admire him.

Requirements/Details:

  • Speak to Animals
Astarion + Lae'zel - His Majesty Last Light Inn - First Floor (close to Barcus Wroot)

Admire His Majesty (the cat) silently.

Requirements/Details:

  • Speak to Animals
Astarion +   His Majesty Last Light Inn - First Floor (close to Barcus Wroot)

Keep the Strange Ox's Secret

Requirement:

  • Speak to Animals
Astarion +     Last Light Inn - 

Tell Rolan "Then it's my responsibility to bring them back" when he tells you about his abducted siblings.

Requirements/Details:

  • Rolan and siblings must have been convinced to accompany the Tieflings at the Emerald Grove
  • When talking to him again right after and choosing the similar answer there might be another approval check (bug?)
Gale ?? Rolan Last Light Inn - First Floor
 

Tell Isobel that Flaming Fist Marcus is trying to kidnap her.

Requirements/Details:

  • Tell him his mission ends now.
  • Speak to Isobel at Last Light Inn
  • Successful Wisdom check to probe Marcus' thoughts DC 6

Karlach +
Shadowheart +
Wyll +

Gale +
Lae'zel 
Minthara
Halsin +
Astarion -

Flaming Fist Marcus
Isobel

Second floor of Last Light Inn - Flaming Fist Marcus will try to order you to kidnap Isobel. After you successfully probe his thoughts with a Wisdom check, you can tell Isobel what he's trying to do.
In the Last Light Inn, after saving the Gnomes in Moonrise Tower and in the Underdark, when Wulbren and Barcus are reuniting, picking option "3. Prick."

Requirements/Details:

  • Save Barcus Wroot from the Windmill in Act 1
  • Save Barcus Wroot from the Drueger in the Grymforge, Underdark
  • Save Wulbren Bongle from Moonrise Tower in Act 2


Karlach +

Astarion +

Halsin -

Wulbren Bongle & Barcus Wroot

Last Light Inn

When finding the Strange Ox again in the Last Light Inn, choose to keeps it's Secret

 

Requirements/Details:

Karlach +   Strange Ox Last Light Inn

 

Reithwin Masons' Guild

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location

Tell Arabella that you'll find her parents

Requirements/Details:

  • Save Arabella at Emerald Grove
  • Find Arabella in Reithwin Masons' Guild
Karlach +
Shadowheart +
N/A Arabella Small graveyard in the Reithwin Masons' Guild - When you find Arabella she'll be looking for her parents. Tell her you'll find them for her.

Tell Arabella that she can stay at your camp

Requirements/Details:

Shadowheart
 +
Wyll +

N/A  Arabella Small graveyard in the Reithwin Masons' Guild - When you find Arabella she'll be looking for her parents. After telling her you'll find them for her, tell her she can stay at camp while she waits for your word.

Drink or mime drinking with Thisobald Thorm

Requirements/Details:

Astarion +
Halsin +
Karlach +
Lae'zel +

N/A Thisobald Thorm The Waning Moon in the Reithwin Masons' Guild - When you approach Thisobald Thorm in The Waning Moon, he'll tell you to drink with him, you can either survive drinking with a Constitution Saving Throw or pretend to drink with a Sleight of Hand check.

Tell Thisobald Thorm a story from your adventures

Requirements/Details:

  • Approach Thisobald Thorm in his bar in The Waning Moon
  • Drink of mime drinking with Thisobald Thorm
  • Succeed a Performance check, or Persuasion check if you're a Warlock, with a DC of 16

Astarion +
Halsin +
Karlach +
Lae'zel +

 N/A Thisobald Thorm The Waning Moon in the Reithwin Masons' Guild - after surviving a drink or pretending to drink with Thisobald Thorm, he'll ask you to regale him with your past. Succeed in the check to tell him a story.

Drink or mime drinking with Thisobald Thorm for a second round

Requirements/Details:

Astarion +
Halsin +
Karlach +
Lae'zel +

N/A Thisobald Thorm The Waning Moon in the Reithwin Masons' Guild - after surviving a drink or pretending to drink with Thisobald Thorm and telling him a story, you can either survive drinking with a Constitution Saving Throw or pretend to drink with a Sleight of Hand check for another round.

Tell Thisobald Thorm another story from your adventures

Requirements/Details:

  • Tell Thisobald Thorm a story after drinking or pretending to drink with him
  • Drink of mime drinking with Thisobald Thorm for another round
  • Succeed a Performance check with 16 DC.

Astarion +
Halsin +
Karlach +
Lae'zel +

N/A Thisobald Thorm The Waning Moon in the Reithwin Masons' Guild - after surviving a drink or pretending to drink with Thisobald Thorm for a second round, he'll ask you to regale him with your past for a second time. Succeed in the Performance check to tell him a story.

Drink or mime drinking with Thisobald Thorm for a third round.

Requirements/Details:

Astarion +
Halsin +
Karlach +
Lae'zel +

N/A Thisobald Thorm The Waning Moon in the Reithwin Masons' Guild - after surviving a drink or pretending to drink with Thisobald Thorm and telling him a story a second time, you can either survive drinking with a Constitution Saving Throw or pretend to drink with a Sleight of Hand check for a third round.

Give Gerringothe Thorm all your gold.

Requirements/Details:

  • Approach Gerringofthe Thorm in the Reithwin Tollhouse
  • Give her a piece of gold and then ask her how much she actually wants
  • Give her all your money
N/A

Astarion -
Karlach -
Shadowheart
 -

Minthara -

Gerringothe Thorm Reithwin Tollhouse in the Reithwin Masons' Guild - when you approach Gerringofthe Thorm in the tollhouse, she'll ask you to pay a toll to be able to pass through. After asking her how much gold she wants, relent to giving her all your gold. This will result in a combat engagement, as it was never going to be enough for her.

Persuade/deceive Gerringothe Thorm that her asking for gold is just a trick.

Requirements/Details:

  • Approach Gerringofthe Thorm in the Reithwin Tollhouse
  • Give her a piece of gold and then ask her how much she actually wants
  • Succed in two Persuation/Deception checks (second is 18)

Halsin 
Lae'zel 
Shadowheart
Karlach
Astarion

N/A

Gerringothe Thorm Reithwin Tollhouse in the Reithwin Masons' Guild - when you approach Gerringofthe Thorm in the tollhouse, she'll ask you to pay a toll to be able to pass through. After asking her how much gold she wants, relent to giving her all your gold. This will result in a combat engagement, as it was never going to be enough for her.

Deceive Gerringothe Thorm that the party is their replacement and they are to be promoted

Requirements/Details:

  • Approach Gerringofthe Thorm in the Reithwin Tollhouse
Shadowheart +
Karlach +
Astarion +
 N/A Gerringothe Thorm Reithwin Tollhouse in the Reithwin Masons' Guild - when you approach Gerringofthe Thorm in the tollhouse, she'll ask you to pay a toll to be able to pass through. After asking her how much gold she wants, relent to giving her all your gold. This will result in a combat engagement, as it was never going to be enough for her.

Defeat Gerringothe Thorm without killing her in battle.

Requirements/Details:

  • Approach Gerringofthe Thorm in the Reithwin Tollhouse
  • Succeed in Skill checks to convince her either that she's running a scam, or that you'll be replacing her as the new toll collector

Astarion +
Halsin +
Karlach +
Lae'zel
 +

Minthara +

N/A Gerringothe Thorm Reithwin Tollhouse in the Reithwin Masons' Guild - when you approach Gerringofthe Thorm in the tollhouse, she'll ask you to pay a toll to be able to pass through.  After you tell her that you don't give away gold for something so little, you'll have options to either convince her that she's running an old scam (if you're a Rogue), or that you'll be replacing her as the new toll collector. Succeed in the Skill checks with increasing DCs to see the conversation through to the end and have her collapse without having to kill her in battle.

Intimidate Gerringothe Thorm to defeat her without killing her in battle.

Requirements/Details:

  • Approach Gerringofthe Thorm in the Reithwin Tollhouse
  • Succeed in a Deception check of 18 DC to convince her that you'll be replacing her as the new toll collector
  • Intimidate her into believing you by succeeding an Intimidation check with 21 DC

 

Astarion +
Halsin +
Karlach +
Lae'zel
 +

Minthara +

 

N/A Gerringothe Thorm Reithwin Tollhouse in the Reithwin Masons' Guild - when you approach Gerringofthe Thorm in the tollhouse, she'll ask you to pay a toll to be able to pass through.  After you tell her that you don't give away gold for something so little, you can tricker and say that you'll be replacing her as the new toll collector. Afterward, you can choose the third option and pass the Intimidation check to push her into believing you.

Have Malus Thorm make the sisters kill each other.

Requirements/Details:

  • Approach Malus Thorm in the House of Healing and say your a student.
  • Succeed a DC 14 Check on any of the options (class appearing means advantage) to see the sister's knives are need practice.
  • Ask him about it and succeed a DC 21 Investigation Check to have them practice on each other.

Astarion +
Shadowheart +
Minthara +

 N/A

Malus Thorm

The House of Healing surgery room speak to Malus Thorm and say your a student. You can succeed any check to see the sisters require practice and bring up the new dialogue option. Then convince him to have the sisters practice on themselves.

Have Malus Thorm Operate on Himself

Requirements/Details:

  • Approach Malus Thorm in the House of Healing and say your a student.
  • Succeed a DC 14 Check on any of the options (class appearing means advantage) to see the sister's need practice.
  • Or Succeed on a Difficult religion Check to remember lessons about Shar
  • You can have the sisters operate on the master or each other (DC 21 Persuasion Check each). Choosing the master kills Malus Thorm. Operating on the sisters first grants more approval.
  • If you didn't operate on him yet, succeed on a DC 21 Deception Check (advantage Sorcerer) to have Malus Thorm demonstrate first, killing him.

Astarion +
Shadowheart +
Lae'zel +
Karlach +

N/A

Malus Thorm

The House of Healing surgery room speak to Malus Thorm and say your a student. You can then succeed any check to see the sisters require practice and bring up the new dialogue option. Then convince him to have the sisters practice on themselves or the master. Practicing on the sisters first grants more approval.

If the sisters are chosen, then deceive Malus Thorm to demonstrate the procedure on himself.

Shadowheart approval will sometimes not proc.

 

Gauntlet of Shar

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location
Talk to Yurgir and ask more than two questions before attacking.

Requirements/Details:

  • Ener the Yurgir's throne room to trigger the conversation (you can encounter them from the side and get into the fight right away without triggering a conversation beforehand)
N/A Astarion - Yurgir Gauntlet of Shar  - East side
Talk to Yurgir and succeed a passuve insight check and convince him to kill his minions, his displacer beast, and then himself.

Requirements/Details:

  • Ener the Yurgir's throne room to trigger the conversation (you can encounter them from the side and get into the fight right away without triggering a conversation beforehand)
  • Passive Insight + Wisdom Check meaning no inspiration Re-rolls.
Astarion +     Yurgir Gauntlet of Shar - East side
Talk to Yurgir about the Displacer Beast then telling him that it's wrong to manipulate the beast in such a way

Requirements/Details:

  • After telling Yurgir you'll look for a way to break his contract
  • You have to know that the Displacer Beast is being charmed by either detecting the thoughts of the Merregon trader or passing the checks on the spider carcass then talking to the Displacer beast with Talk to Animals
Shadowheart + 
Halsin +
  Yurgir, Displacer Beast Gauntlet of Shar 
Tell Astarion you'll help him take the fight to Cazador

Requirements/Details:

  • End the Day after killing Yurgir.
  • Make Raphael tell the back story about Astarion's scar.

Astarion +

N/A Raphael N/A

Convince Balthazar to aid you in search of the relic

Requirements/Details:

Astarion +
Shadowheart +
N/A Balthazar Within the Gauntlet of Shar - Go inside a room located west at (X:-851 Y:-786) and speak to Balthazar.

Use BARD Persuation option to convince Balthazar to give you extra resources.

Requirements/Details:

Shadowheart + N/A Balthazar Within the Gauntlet of Shar - Go inside a room located west at (X:-851 Y:-786) and speak to Balthazar.

Tell Balthazar that;
You have resources to spare - give me something to aid my search

This will ask Balthazar to give you the Bell to summon Flesh

Requirements/Details:

  • Progress in Infiltrate Moonrise Towers
  • Don't turn hostile against Balthazar's Undead Servants to be able to talk to him.
Astarion +  n/a  Balthazar  Within the Gauntlet of Shar - Go inside a room located west at (X:-851 Y:-786) and speak to Balthazar.

Tell Balthazar that;

  • <Wizard> "The Nightsong's a person. Balthazar, this is an affront to the Weave itself"
  • <Cleric> "You will torture this angel-born no longer"

This will lead to a battle with Balthazar

Requirements/Details:

  • Progress in Infiltrate Moonrise Towers
  • Don't turn hostile against Balthazar's Undead Servants to be able to talk to him.
  • Progress in the Gauntlet of Shar and meet the Nightsong
 Halsin  n/a  Balthazar  Gauntlet of Shar - Nightsong's Prison

Tell the Rat that;
"All right. Your lives for this treasure"

Requirements/Details:

  • Progress in Infiltrate Moonrise Towers
  • Don't Attack the Rat
Halsin + Astarion - Rat Rat by the Lyrthindor Ritual Sigil within Gauntlet of Shar

Lick the Dead Spider Meat

Requirements/Details:

  • Interact with the dead spider at this location (X:-648 Y:-724).
Karlach +

Shadowheart -

Gale -

N/A Within the Gauntlet of Shar - After dealing with Yurgir, continue heading north until you reach this location (X:-648 Y:-724) and interact with the Spider Meat.

After she asks you to, let Shadowheart do the trials, after you first interacted with the Sacrificial Bowls with another character.

Requirements/Details:

  • Once you're about to start the Sharran Trials, interact with the Sacrificial Bowl, then choose to let Shadowheart offer her blood to the bowl.
Shadowheart + N/A N/A Within the Gauntlet of Shar - Just northwest of the Gauntlet of Shar Waypoint, the Soft-step Trial can be found here (X:-761 Y:-755), then interact with the Sacrificial Bowl.

While Shadowheart is praying, peer into her mind

Requirements/Details:

  • Before entering the Shadowfell Entrance, peer inside Shadowheart's mind while she's praying to Lady Shar.
N/A Shadowheart - N/A Within the Gauntlet of Shar - Once you've been transported down the Inner Sanctum, interact with the Ancient Altar and place three Umbral Gems you've collected to unlock the door ahead. Go down the stairs and interact with the Shadowfell Entrance.

Before entering the Shadowfell Entrance, agree with Shadowheart about the sacrifice she needs to perform for Lady Shar

Requirements/Details:

  • Interact with the Shadowfell Entrance, then choose the option "All right. Fine. Let's move on." after Shadowheart says that Lady Shar's reward aligns with your own interests. 
Shadowheart + N/A N/A Within the Gauntlet of Shar - Once you've been transported down the Inner Sanctum, interact with the Ancient Altar and place three Umbral Gems you've collected to unlock the door ahead. Go down the stairs and interact with the Shadowfell Entrance.

Convince Shadowheart to spare Nightsong and hear what she has to say

Requirements/Details:

  • Once you reach Nightsong at this location (X:-606 Y:-1435) in Nightsong's Prison, try to convince Shadowheart not to kill Nightsong.
  • If you fail to persuade her, she will say that if she has to step over your corpse to fulfill Lady Shar's wishes, she will do it. At this instance, do not choose the option to fight her and let her do what she must. Depending on your bond, she will hesitate for a moment and eventually throw the spear and not kill Nightsong.
Karlach + N/A Nightsong Within the Gauntlet of Shar - Interact with the Shadowfell Entrance to reach Nightsong's Prison, then reach this location (X:-606 Y:-1435) and interact with Nightsong.

 

House of Healing

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location
Convince the sisters to practice on themselves

Requirement/s:

 

Astarion +

n/a Malus Thorm and the Sisters

House of Healing - 

Convince Malus Thorm to kill himself

Requirement/s:

 

Astarion +

  Malus Thorm and the Sisters House of Healing -  

 

 

Moonrise Towers

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location
When speaking to both Barnabus and Linsella; pick "[Wisdom] Sever her control once and for all"

This will kill Linsella

Requirement/s:

  • Gain entry to Moonrise Towers
  • Don't attack the characters

Astarion +

Halsin +

Karlach +

n/a Barnabus and Linsella Moonrise Towers - Main Floor - Kitchen
When speaking to both Barnabus and Linsella; pick "Reinforce her efforts with your own"

Requirement/s:

  • Gain entry to Moonrise Towers
  • Don't attack the characters

n/a

Astarion - Barnabus and Linsella Moonrise Towers - Main Floor - Kitchen
When asked by Araj Oblodra "I assume he belongs to you?" referring to Astarion, respond to her with: "Excuse me? He's his own person."

Requirement/s:

  • Gain entry to Moonrise Towers
  • Don't attack the characters

Astarion +

Karlach +

n/a Araj Oblodra Moonrise Towers - Main Floor
Force Astarion to bite Araj Oblodra after he expressly refused her wish.

Requirement/s:

  • Gain entry to Moonrise Towers
  • Don't attack the characters
n/a Astarion - Araj Oblodra Moonrise Towers - Main Floor

When meeting Ketheric Thorm and Z'Rell the first time,

Fezzerk: Please - You Gotta Help Me! For old times' sake?
Tell him to "Spill your guts on the floor. I want to see you bleed."

Requirement/s:

  • Don't kill Fezzerk's Crew at the Windmill where Barcus Wroot is strapped on.
  • Gain entry to Moonrise Towers
  • Don't attack the characters
Astarion + Wyll -
Karlach -
Fezzerk, Ketheric Thorm Moonrise Towers - Main Floor

When meeting Ketheric Thorm and Z'Rell the first time, kill the goblins yourself by telling them they shouldn't breath anymore and choking them to death.

Requirement/s:

  • Don't kill Fezzerk's Crew at the Windmill where Barcus Wroot is strapped on.
  • Gain entry to Moonrise Towers
  • Don't attack the characters
Astarion + Wyll -
Karlach -
FezzerkKetheric Thorm Moonrise Towers - Main Floor

When meeting Ketheric Thorm and Z'Rell the first time while also being a Dark Urge Character

Fezzerk: Please - You Gotta Help Me! For old times' sake?
Tell him to "I dream of blood pools deep enough to bathe in. Run me a bath."

Requirement/s:

  • Don't kill Fezzerk's Crew at the Windmill where Barcus Wroot is strapped on.
  • Gain entry to Moonrise Towers
  • Don't attack the characters
  • Be a Dark Urge Character
Astarion +   FezzerkKetheric Thorm Moonrise Towers - Main Floor

When meeting Ketheric Thorm and Z'Rell the first time, kill the goblins via the Paladin option of choosing Trial by Combat.

Requirement/s:

  • Don't kill Fezzerk's Crew at the Windmill where Barcus Wroot is strapped on.
  • Gain entry to Moonrise Towers
  • Don't attack the characters
Wyll +
Karlach +
Astarion - Fezzerk Moonrise Towers - Main Floor
Show mercy on the goblins by setting them free.

Requirement/s:

  • Gain entry to Moonrise Towers
  • Don't attack the characters
n/a

Astarion -
  
Halsin -
Karlach
 - 
Lae'zel -

Fezzerk Moonrise Towers - Main Floor
Reject the soul coins being passed along by Flo through Lann Tarv

Requirement/s:

  • Gain entry to Moonrise Towers
  • Don't attack the characters
 n/a Karlach - Lann Tarv Moonrise Towers - Main Floor
Tell Jaheira "It would be my honor" when she asks if you will take the final steps together.

Requirement/s:

  • Gain entry to Moonrise Towers
Karlach +  n/a Jaheira Moonrise Towers - Bridge
Before fighting Ketheric Thorm on the rooftop, tell him: "I can help you, Ketheric- if you let me."

Requirement/s:

  • Gain entry to Moonrise Towers
Karlach +  n/a Ketheric Thorm Moonrise Towers - Rooftop

Before fighting Ketheric Thorm on the rooftop, tell him:

  • "It isn't too late, your story doesn't end here"
  • "Wait - Ketheric has surrendered"

    Requirement/s:
  • Gain entry to Moonrise Towers
  • Go to Moonrise Towers - Rooftop
Halsin + x2   Ketheric Thorm  Moonrise Towers - Rooftop

After you defeat Ketheric Throm, talk to Art Cullagh in Moonrise Towers and say "I just killed Kethric and this is all you have to say?"

 

Requirement/s:

  • Defeated Ketheric Throm
Astarion + Halsin - Art Cullagh Moonrise Towers - 

After you defeat Ketheric Throm, talk to Thaniel while in Moonrise Tower

 

Requirement/s:

  • Defeated Ketheric Throm
  • Oliver and Thaniel Reunited
Halsin +    Thaniel and Oliver Moonrise Towers - 

Mind Flayer Colony

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location
Free the prisoners and Mind Flayers from the pods.

Requirement/s:

  • Jump down the Hollow Tower
Karlach + Astarion - Zevlor Mind Flayer Colony - Tadpoling Centre
Kill Mizora

Requirement/s:

  • Killing Mizora will lead to Wyll being dragged to Avernus
   Karlach - Mizora  Mind Flayer Colony -
Agree to take on the knowledge of the Waking Mind.

Requirement/s:

Astarion+     Mind Flayer Colony -

Camp/Companion/Event Interactions

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location

Tell Elminster, "If even the gods know, why are we facing these threats alone?"

Requirements/Details:

Gale + N/A Elminster Aumar Camp
While in Camp, tell Arabella that you found her parents dead

Requirement/s:

  • Approach Arabella and Withers in Camp, then if Arabella asks if you found her parents, tell them you did, but you found their corpses.

Gale +
Astarion +
Shadowheart +
Wyll +

N/A Withers Camp
While in Camp, choos the BARD option to tell Arabella that you found her parents dead

Requirement/s:

  • Approach Arabella and Withersin Camp, then if Arabella asks if you found her parents, tell them you did, but you found their corpses.

Lae'zel +

none Withers Camp

When talking to Wyll after talking to Counselor Florrick in the Last Light Inn, tell Wyll "To Moonrise, then. We can't let the Absolute rake Grand Duke Ravengard."

Requirement/s:

Wyll +  none Wyll Camp

Hug Karlach after Dammon fixed her engine.

Requirement/s:

Karlach +  none Karlach Camp

Tell Halsin you wished he had joined earlier.

Requirement/s:

Halsin +  none Halsin Camp

Ask Halsin about something about him "one wouldn't think to ask" and tell him "thank you for sharing"

Requirement/s:

  • Halsin has become a Companion
Halsin +  none Halsin Camp

Tell Halsin you're afraid of Kraken

Requirement/s:

  • Halsin has become a Companion
Halsin +  none Halsin Camp

After you ask Halsin about his family, friends and lovers tell him "sorry for your loss"

Requirement/s:

  • Halsin has become a Companion
Halsin +  none Halsin Camp

When Voss visits you at your camp, tell Lae'zel that he speaks true about zaith'isk.

Requirements:

  • Don't kill the Dream Guardian in the Artefact
Shadowheart + N/A Kith'rak Voss Camp - Event

Lump the Enlightened will try to collect payment owed to him, pay Lump the Enlightened and let him lick you.

 

Requirements:

Shadowheart +
Astarion +
  Lump the Enlightened Camp - Event

After rescuing Ketheric and rescued Mizora, you can get into a conversation with him. Here is a bunch of possible sources of approval

  • Letting Wyll into your mind to see your memories
  • Telling him its a Brave/Frightening Choice
  • Express approval for the brave thing Wyll did for Baldur's Gate
  • Quests: The Blade of Frontiers.

 

Requirements:

  • Defeat Ketheric Thorm
  • Rescued Mizora from the Mind Flayer Colony
Wyll +   Wyll Camp/Companion Interaction

 

Baldur's Gate 3 Act 3 Dialog Scenarios Quick Navigation

Click to jump to a specific section of the page

Rivington ♦

Rivington

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub-Location

When finding the Protestors who dislike the refugees (Saer Grotpoll)

  • Say "out with the refugees"

Astarion +

Jaheira -

Halsin -

Saer Grotpoll Rivington

When finding the Protestors who dislike the refugees (Saer Grotpoll)

  • Say his accent is Rivingtonian
Jaheira +   Saer Grotpoll Rivington

When finding the Protestors who dislike the refugees;

  • Say Saer's Accent is Rivingtonian
Jaheira +    Saer Grotpoll  Rivington

Tell Flaming Fist Nestor that;

  • "I'll take a donation Please"

Astarion +

  Manip Nestor Rivington - Refugee Camp

Donate 500 Gold

Jaheira

Halsin

 Astarion Manip Nestor Rivington - Refugee Camp

Tell Gyldro Angleiron (Orin)

  • "I would never hurt someone I care about"

Jaheira

Halsin

 

Gyldro Angleiron

Orin

The Rivington General

Tell Yenna you don't know anything about her mother but give her some gold

 

Requirements:

  • Enter Rivingtion after exciting the first camp in Act 3
  • Automatic coversation after entering Rivington for the first time

Astarion +

Jaheira +

Halsin +

N/A Yenna Rivingtion - Southern Village Entrance

Tell Biscoti he's a good boy.

 

Requirements:

  • Speak with Animals
Halsin + N/A Biscotti Rivingtion - Refugee Camp

Tell Fist Rowan that the people are innocent and you can't just kill them.

Requirements:

Jaheira +

Halsin +

Astarion Fist Rowan Rivingtion - Side Entrance to the donations barn from the refugee camp (next to the Hobgoblin)

Tell Tinker Nayzeen that the way the refugees are treated is horrible.

Requisites:

-

Jaheira +

Halsin 

N/A Tinker Nayzeen Rivingtion - Refugee Camp

In the Open Hand Temple when talking to Ilmater, telling Tara to stop eating the pigeons

 

Requisites:

-

Halsin + Astarion - Ilmater Open Hand Temple - one of the buildings close to the entrance of the Lower City.

During the final part of the Help the Cursed Monk quest where you can take on the curse, accept the curse

 

Requisites:

  • Picked up the Sentient Amulet in Grymforge in Act 1
Wyll +
Astarion +
Shadowheart +
  Sentient Amulet Open Hand Temple - Cursed Monk Dungeon.

During the final part of the Help the Cursed Monk quest where you can take on the curse, accept the curse and then win the 2nd wisdom check.

 

Requisites:

  • Picked up the Sentient Amulet in Grymforge in Act 1
Wyll +
Astarion +
Shadowheart 
Jahira +
  Sentient Amulet Open Hand Temple - Cursed Monk Dungeon.

Keep responding with "Woof! at angry Mar'hyah

 

Requisites:

-

Shadowheart +
Astarion +
  Angry Mar'hyah Rivingtion - Outside of Sword Coast Couriers.

Respond to Wulbren with either "Get the bomb inside the Gondian facility, and - boom. Problem solved." or 
"[Rogue] Sneak in, place the bomb, sneak out - bang. Sounds simple enough"

 

Requisites:

-

Jaheira +
Wyll +
Karlach -
Halsin -
Wulbren Bongle Rivington - Angleiron’s Cellar

Choose "Try and Help Him" with you encounter the Dying Stone Lord Thug

 

Requisites:

-

Jaheira +
Wyll +
  Dying Stone Lord Thug Rivington - In the western area smuggling cove, you will encounter him on the path.

 

Circus of the Last Days

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location

When speaking to Shadow-Whiskers (Big Black Cat in a Cage) exhaust conversation until Halsin speaks about the inhumanity. Then "Break the lock, ensuring the cage can't be opened"

Halsin +

  Shadow-Whiskers Circus of the Last Days

When Dribbles the Clown asks his scarecrow question use the [BARD] option to answer.

 

Requirement/s:

  •  Bard

Astarion +

Jaheira +

Halsin +

 N/A Dribbles the Clown Circus of the Last Days - You can find Dribbles the Clown performing on stage for a crowd on the northern side of the Circus.

When Dribbles the Clown asks you to come on stage choose Astarion instead.

 

Requirement/s:

Jaheira +

Halsin +

Astarion - Dribbles the Clown Circus of the Last Days - You can find Dribbles the Clown performing on stage for a crowd on the northern side of the Circus.

When Dribbles the Clown asks you to come on stage choose Astarion instead and ask him to enter the stage a second time.

 

Requirement/s:

  • Ask Astarion to go on stage

Jaheira +

Astarion - Dribbles the Clown Circus of the Last Days - You can find Dribbles the Clown performing on stage for a crowd on the northern side of the Circus.

When Dribbles the Clown asks you to come on stage choose Jaheira instead.

 

Requirement/s:

Halsin +

N/A Dribbles the Clown Circus of the Last Days - You can find Dribbles the Clown performing on stage for a crowd on the northern side of the Circus.

When Dribbles the Clown asks you to come on stage choose Jaheira instead and ask him to enter the stage a second time by saying "All hail the High Harper".

 

Requirement/s:

  • Ask Jaheira to go on stage

Halsin +

Jaheira - Dribbles the Clown Circus of the Last Days - You can find Dribbles the Clown performing on stage for a crowd on the northern side of the Circus.

When Dribbles the Clown asks you to come on stage choose Jaheira instead and ask him to enter the stage a second time by saying "Get on with it".

 

Requirement/s:

  • Ask Jaheira to go on stage

Halsin +

N/A Dribbles the Clown Circus of the Last Days - You can find Dribbles the Clown performing on stage for a crowd on the northern side of the Circus.

When Dribbles the Clown asks you to come on stage choose Halsin instead.

 

Requirement/s:

Jaheira +

N/A Dribbles the Clown Circus of the Last Days - You can find Dribbles the Clown performing on stage for a crowd on the northern side of the Circus.

When Dribbles the Clown asks you to come on stage choose Halsin instead and ask him to enter the stage a second time.

 

Requirement/s:

  • Ask Halsin to go on stage

Halsin +
Jaheira +

N/A Dribbles the Clown Circus of the Last Days - You can find Dribbles the Clown performing on stage for a crowd on the northern side of the Circus.

Pick 'My strength of course' when Dribbles asks what makes you special

 

Requirement/s:

  • Get onto the stage when Dribbles asks for volunteers for his magic trick.
  • Don't start the combat encounter/attack Dribbles before getting on stage.

Astarion +

Jaheira +

Halsin +

 N/A Dribbles the Clown Circus of the Last Days - You can find Dribbles the Clown performing on stage for a crowd on the northern side of the Circus.

Pick 'My courage' when Dribbles asks what makes you special

 

Requirement/s:

  • Get onto the stage when Dribbles asks for volunteers for his magic trick.
  • Don't start the combat encounter/attack Dribbles before getting on stage.

Jaheira +

Halsin +

 N/A Dribbles the Clown Circus of the Last Days - You can find Dribbles the Clown performing on stage for a crowd on the northern side of the Circus.

Pick 'Kindness' when Dribbles asks what makes you special

 

Requirement/s:

  • Get onto the stage when Dribbles asks for volunteers for his magic trick.
  • Don't start the combat encounter/attack Dribbles before getting on stage.

Jaheira +

Halsin +

 N/A Dribbles the Clown Circus of the Last Days - You can find Dribbles the Clown performing on stage for a crowd on the northern side of the Circus.

During Zethino's Trial of Love with Halsin. Choose the following choices for approval

 

Requirement/s:

  • Choose the "Bear Form" dialogue
  • Choose "Protecting The Grove"
  • Choose  "The Shadow Grow Curse"
Halsin +   N/A  Zethino Circus of the Last Days -

 

Wyrm's Rock

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location
Tell the Guard on the bridge that Investigator Valeria needs you in the Lower City.

Requirement/s:

  • n/a
Astarion + n/a Blaze Elin Wyrm's Crossing

During the ceremony, a Steel Watcher will ask you to stop. Cooperate with its request by choosing "Point taken. I'll keep things peaceful."

  • Act 3

Requirement/s:

  • Watch the inauguration of Lord Enver Gortash
Astarion + n/a Steel Watcher Wyrm's Rock Fortress

When Gortash invites you to watch the ceremony, choose the "I wouldn't dream of missing it."

  • Act 3

Requirement/s:

  • Stay after the ceremony
Astarion + Karlach - 
Wyll -
Lord Enver Gortash Wyrm's Rock Fortress

When Gortash invites you to watch the ceremony, choose the "Fine. Let's get it over with"

  • Act 3

Requirement/s:

  • Stay after the ceremony
Wyll +    Lord Enver Gortash Wyrm's Rock Fortress

When Gortash invites you to watch the ceremony, choose the "I have no interest in this sham of a ceremony."

  • Act 3

Requirement/s:

  • Stay after the ceremony
Wyll +   Lord Enver Gortash Wyrm's Rock Fortress

After the ceremony, Karlach will confront you and ask what you think of Gortash. Choose "He seemed like an absolute fraud in a very nice coat."

  • Act 3

Requirement/s:

  • Stay after the ceremony
Karlach + n/a Karlach Wyrm's Rock Fortress

Tell Duke Ulder Ravengard that he is infected with an Illithid parasite.

  • Act 3

Requirement/s:

  • Stay after the ceremony
Astarion + n/a Duke Ulder Ravengard Wyrm's Rock Fortress

In the Fire First dorms, offer gold to Fist Reynash by saying "Will this get you home?"

  • Act 3

Requirement/s:

  • Explore the hallways after the ceremony.
n/a Astarion - First Reynash Wyrm's Rock Fortress

Convince Florick to let you out of Prison.

Requirement/s:

  • Can be a Persuasion and Intimidation DC Check.
Karlach +
Wyll +
  Counsellor Florrick Wyrm's Rock Fortress

 

Lower City

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location

In the Guildhall, tell Nine-Fingers Keene that you're a friend of Jaheira's.

  • Act 3

Requirement/s:

  • Must have Jaheira in your party
Jaheira + n/a Nine-Fingers Keene Guildhall

In the Guildhall, tell Nine-Fingers Keene that you're a friend of Jaheira's.

  • Act 3

Requirement/s:

  • Must have Jaheira in your party
Jaheira + n/a Nine-Fingers Keene Guildhall
When Jaheira returns home, tell Rion "The cult is powerful- it's not going to be an easy fight."
  • Act 3

Requirement/s:

  • Must have Jaheira in your party
Karlach + n/a Rion Lower City

 In Devil's Fee, while talking to Helsik, persuade her to get a free sample.

  • Act 3

Requirement/s:

  • Choose the Persuasion check and succeed the DC of 10.
Astarion + n/a Helsik Lower City - Devil's Fee

 

Lorroakan's Tower

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub-Location

Tell Lorroakan you'll send the Nightsong to rip him apart

Requirements:

  • Spared the Nightsong
Karlach + N/A Lorroakan Lorroakan's Tower

 

The Blushing Mermaid

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location

When you meet Auntie Ethel again in act 3 in the Blushing Mermaid. Tell Ethel that Mayrina says hi when she vomits up Varna

Requirement/s:

  • Could be part of the big quest Save Vanra that revolves around Auntie Ethel and her victims.
Astarion + n/a Auntie Ethel Blushing Mermaid

Tell Mayrena “it’s better than nothing” when she gives you the locket after the Hag battle. 

Requirement/s:

  • Could be part of the big quest Save Vanra that revolves around Auntie Ethel and her victims.
Shadowheart +   Mayrina Blushing Mermaid

 

Candulhallow’s Tombstones

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location

If you bring Jaheira when you go and meet the Murder Tribunal/Sarevok. The old history between the ancient adversaries will raise the tensions. (Sarevok was the Antagonist of BG 1 and Jaheira fought against him with the Hero Bhaalspawn). Choose to side with Jaheira.

Requirement/s:

Jaheira +   Jaheira , Sarevok Candulhallow's Tombstones -

 

 

Camp Interactions

Scenario Details Approval Disapproval Related NPC Sub- Location

When talking to Jaheira in Camp at Act 3.

  • "Please. You're only one of those things", after asking that she has fought the Dead Three before
  • "My mind is my own", when asking about what she knows about Illithids
Jaheira + x2   Jaheira

Camp

Keep Scratch after talking to the Sword Coast Couriers

 

Requirement/s:

  • Speak to Oyster Boy Dringo and Angry Mar'hyah of the Sword Coast Couriers.
  • Choose 'He lives with me - you can't just take him' when talking about Scratch's ownership.
  • Return to Camp to speak to Scratch. You'll need Speak with Animals.
Gale +
Wyll +
  Angry Mar'hyah, Oyster Boy Dringo, and Scratch

Rivington - Out in the yard of the Sword Coast Couriers, the 'post office' of the village.

Camp

Astarion's siblings confront you in your camp, you get approval if you tell him "The world can be a wonderful, kind place"

 

Requirement/s:

  • Killed Cazador
Astarion +   Astarion

Camp - Event

 

Baldur's Gate 3 Companion Approval Quick Navigation

Click to jump to a specific section of the page

 

Astarion

Approval Up
Deceive Tieflings and ask Lae'zel to say "please" before freeing her from the cage. Join Lae'zel against the Tieflings if you persuade them to free her. Attack Tieflings (in dialog) even if Lae'zel is still in the cage.
In the map facing towards the Druid Grove entrance with the Waypoint Silvanus' Grove in line to your right— head down the path to the left for Novice Brynna and the Exsanguinated Boar (appears after Astarion sneaks away on a Long Rest). Choose to attack Taman and Gimblebock in dialogue outside the Crypt. After using your Illithid power against Novice Brynna ask what happened to their brother, and then send them to the Owlbear Nest to avenge True Soul Edowin.
Talk to Astarion after and say, "The Tadpoles aren't so bad." Loot True Soul Edowin's body, then crush the Tadpole that comes out. Talk to Astarion again and say "They practically worshipped us. That could be useful"
Try to persuade the goblin Guard outside the Blighted Village. In the broken house opposite the portal, Search the Cellar in the Blighted Village and Intimidate the Ornate Mirror. Decline the Devil's invitation to remove your Tadpole.
Respond to Volo in the Goblin Camp with "-". Kneel down and lick Novice Crusher's foot in the Goblin Camp (Starts a battle). Let Astarion suck your blood in Camp.
Support Astarion in the dialogue with the team after the bite in the Camp. Tell him he can feed on enemies. Persuade him to share his dream with you.
Say you cover him up ( ... if he covers you” - also works) in the same dialogue. Kill Gandrel (the hunter who is located nearby Ethel's home). Agree to help tiefling Karlach.
In the conversation with Shadowheart (after the dream with the city in fire) support the Astarion's idea to continue usage of Tadpoles' power. (After the next dream) say to Wyll that you are not going to excuse for using Tadpoles' power. Let Arka kill Sazza in the Druid Camps Makeshift Prison.
Tell Zorru at the Druid Camp that he better bow to Lae'zel when she tells him too. Tell Astarion that the refugees are desperate, and will do anything right after that. Tell Mattis he's getting "Paid in experience ... " after pocketing the ring.
Tell Kagha the Archdruid you enjoyed her show when she asks if you think she's a monster. Choose to walk in on a bugbear and an ogre named Grukkoh and Buthir having sex at the north side of the Blighted Village in an abandoned barn. (Let Astarion do the honors.) Tell that it was fun right after that.
Tell Mayrina's brothers they are on their own. “Baaa” back at redcaps pretending to be sheep (works the first and second time). Resurrect Mayrina's husband, give her the staff, and right after that tell Astarion that's funny.
Talk to True Soul Gut in the Goblin Camp, after she knows you have a Tadpole as well say, "Can we talk privately? This is a sensitive matter." Follow her and talk to her in the chapel and say, "Change of plan. I'm going to kill you." Demand boots in the dialogue with Tulla ( in the Underdark, mushrooms camp). Agree to kill dark dwarfs for “mushrooms” leader.
Do not excuse for using the power of Tadpoles ( dialogue with the party at the Camp). Tell Abdirak you're curious and agree to be tortured (the follower of Loviatar in the goblin camp). Agree to open the gate for goblin raiders.
Open the Gate for goblin raiders. Join Minthara for the Grove raid ( It's possible without actual opening the Gates). Fight the fake god Boooal in The Festering Cove.
Let the Koa-Toes bow to you as the Boooal's chosen. Ask for "Compensation for Effort" in dialogue with Bark Root (the guy who was tied to the windmill). Attack the Druid Apprentice Nettie.
Agree to share your bed with him at the Tiefling party at Camp. Choose the option to "Bare your neck, inviting him" in the bed scene. Kill Githyanki patrol.
Agree to kill duergars (dark dwarfs) for myconids leader. Intimidate or provoke human and Zevlor at the Druid Grove. Choose decapitation during night 2 dialogue at the Camp.
Kill Gimblebock and the gang near the ruins. Give him the Necromancy of Thay. Attack Goblin Camp.
Volunteer to torture Liam at Goblin Camp. Agree to play chicken chase, at the Goblin Camp, then convince the owlbear to kill the goblins (“Animal handling: turn his gaze to the goblins – they deserve to die”) Feed Owlbear at the Camp.
Decline when Halsin asks to kill Goblin leaders. Laugh/Roar at Lorin (elf in Ethel's house) by pretending that you are the monster he sees. Choose to kill Kagha without trying to persuade her.
Choose to spare Auntie Ethel when they surrender during the battle. In camp, giving your preferred method of death if you first answered that you didn't want to die. (Upon speaking with Shadowheart after dream sequence) Say "The parasites have proved useful ..." when confronted by the camp.
After buying Oskar the artist in the Zhentarim Hideout (which gives Astarion approval down), call him your slave and say you don't make jokes with your slaves. Encourage True Soul Nere to kill the slaves. Persuade the Owlbear that the Goblins caused its pain.
Shuffle the lanceboard in the game between Mol and Raphael at the Last Light Inn Drink or mime drinking with Thisobald Thorm at The Waning Moon Tell Thisobald Thorm a story from your adventures
Drink or mime drinking with Thisobald Thorm for a second round at The Waning Moon Tell Thisobald Thorm another story from your adventures Drink or mime drinking with Thisobald Thorm for a third round at The Waning Moon
Intimidate Gerringothe Thorm to defeat her without killing her in battle While in Camp, tell Arabella you found her parents dead. Convince Balthazar to aid you in search of the relic.
Agree that you’ll help him in taking the fight to Cazador. Tell Dribbles the Clown that your Strength makes you unique at the Circus of the Last Days. In Devil's Fee, while talking to Helsik, persuade her to give you a free sample.
     

 

Approval Down
After using your Illithid power, talk to Astarion and say, "It could destroy us." Agree to help Wyll save the refugees in the Druid Grove. Question his attitude towards the controlled fishermen at Nautiloid wreckage.
(Warlock Only) Say “He’s only a Cambion, we can handle him.” in camp dialogue after receiving the offer from the Devil. Say that the Druids overreacted when speaking to Marriko and Locke in the Druid Grove. Insisting on continuing to be honest about having the tadpole in dialogue with Shadowheart after killing Nettie.
Tell Silfy to "relax" after interrupting her attempt to pickpocket you.  Agree to help Zevlor. Smear dung on your face for Sentinel Olak.
Let True Soul Gut in the Goblin Camp clear your mind OR Let True Soul Gut brand you. Take the poison from the Druid apprentice. Agree to help find Mayrina (On the way to Auntie Ethel).
Tell Mayrina that her brothers are dead "by your own hand". Insist on helping Mayrina when talking to Auntie Ethel at her house. Read the Necromancy of Thay or give it to Gale.
(After giving him the Necromancy of Thay) Say "Gale would take it off your hands" or "Then stop reading it!" Persuade the Tiefling and Human to calm down when they're arguing at Druid Grove. It doesn't appear as though he will approve of any of the options available. Reveal his identity to the monster hunter.
Failing the persuasion check asking him to explain his dream. Killing Mayrina's zombie husband after bringing him back with the Hag's wand. Promise Nettie to take Wyvern Poison if you feel symptoms of the tadpole (after intimidating/persuading/deceiving her).
At camp, when talking about your preferred method of death say you'd rather have one of the others do it, or that you don't have to choose. At camp, when the owlbear cub comes with a dead bird as a gift, eat it. At Grymforge, replying "I'll do what I can" to the two gnomes - Lunkbug and Apprentice Laridda - digging to free True Soul Nere and wanting to free their friends.
(Upon speaking with Shadowheart after dream sequence) Say "We should stop using the parasites ..." when confronted by the camp. When speaking with Eight (child on the far eastern side of the goblin camp), Say "Sorry for your loss" after asking about a corpse.  Buy Oskar the artist.
Give Oskar the artist gold after freeing him. Stop True Soul Nere from killing the slaves. Telling him to mind his own business when he asks about your night of passion with your romance partner.
Release Dolly Dolly Dolly from the Moonlantern Get caught by Oliver's "family" in the Ruined Battlefield Drink the wine prepared by Jaheira at the Last Light Inn
Give Gerringothe Thorm all your gold    

 

Shadowheart

Approval Up
Telling Shadowheart in Camp that making finding the healer your top priority rewards you with Approval. Calm the Scared Boar by the crash site (Animal Handling), or telling it to calm down (Speaks with Animals). Persuade Taman and Gimblebock to leave without a fight in dialogue outside the Crypt.
Succeed in a Religion check when reading the Book of Dead Gods. Show Guex in the Druid Grove your sword fighting technique. Persuade Arka that killing Sazza means she'll take everything to the grave.
In the conversation with Shadowheart after speaking with Sazza and learning about Gut, "You're right. We have to investigate all leads, no matter how unsavoury." After saving Nadira from the Bugbear Assassin in the Grove, use Deception to convince her to give you the soul coin. Tell Novice Andrick and Novice Brynna to forget the Owlbear and leave.
Crush the Tadpole outside of the Druid Grove. Swear to Nettie you will take the poison. Convince the Owlbear not to kill you in its cave.
Tell Scratch (dog) that he can come to your Camp if his friend doesn't wake up. ”Baaa” back at redcaps pretending to be sheep (works the first and second time) Resist during the first Dream sequence.
Fight the fake god Boooal in The Festering Cove. Decline the Devil's invitation to remove your Tadpole. Refuse to play chicken chase with the owlbear in the Goblin Camp, then speak to it and give it your scent to follow to camp.
Make Novice Crusher kiss your foot in the Goblin Camp (approval both for passing the check to tell him to, and also the check to actually make him kiss it) Kiss his foot and steal the ring Lick his foot (Starts a battle)
Give his foot a kiss and get it over with Talk to True Soul Gut in the Goblin Camp, after she knows you have a Tadpole as well say, "Can we talk privately? This is a sensitive matter." Follow her and talk to her in the chapel and say, "Change of plan. I'm going to kill you." Choosing Stay silent option when confronting Kagha about the fate of Arabella.
Telling Silver (with animal talking potion on) that you talked to him just to give him your scent. (Upon speaking with Shadowheart after dream sequence) Say "We should stop using the parasites ..." when confronted by the camp. When speaking with Eight (child on the far eastern side of the goblin camp), Say "Sorry for your loss" after asking about a corpse.
Intimidate or persuade Zarys in the Zhentarim hideout  (i.e., tell her to stand down or say you don't want trouble) Say you want to buy Oskar the artist in the  Zhentarim hideout (“Fine, I’ll buy him. How much?”) and then successfully persuade or intimidate his slaver (Brem) Allow Wyll to play "how would you kill the Blade" when talking to three goblins in the Shattered Sanctum.
Let the Owlbear Cub in the Owlbear Nest live after killing its mother. Welcome Owlbear to camp. Persuade Booyahg Piddle to give up the reading the book and pray instead.
Persuade the goblin at the entrance to the Blighted Village to let you through peacefully. Persuade the goblins at the Windmill in the Blighted Village to leave peacefully. Play hide and seek with Oliver
Tell Isobel that Flaming Fist Marcus is trying to kidnap her Tell Arabella that you'll find her parents Tell Arabella that she can stay at your camp
While in Camp, tell Arabella you found her parents dead. Convince Balthazar to aid you in search of the relic. Within the Gauntlet of Shar - Before starting the Sharran Trials, interact with the Sacrificial Bowl and let her do as she pleases.
Convince Balthazar to aid you in search of the relic. Within the Gauntlet of Shar - Before entering the Shadowfell Entrance, agree with her about the sacrifice she needs to perform for Lady Shar.  
APPROVAL EXPLOIT
After discovering a damaged helmet on a body in the Blighted Village and passing a few skill checks in dialogue with Shadowheart, you can get her to reveal her worship of Shar.
After this, the following dialogue option can be repeated in camp to gain infinite approval increase:
We should get to know each other better. Tell me something about yourself besides Shar, besides tadpoles. You'll have to point out night orchids to me if we ever pass some.

 

Approval Down
Join Lae'Zel against the Tieflings if you Persuade them to free her. Agree to help Wyll save the refugees in the Druid Grove. Tell Auntie Ethel you have a tadpol in your head at the Druid Grove.
Try to persuade the goblin guard outside the Goblin Camp. Let True Soul Gut brand you. Help Auntie Ethel when she's confronted by Johl and Demir.
Agree to allow Auntie Ethel to remove your Tadpole. Smear dung on your face for Sentinel Olak. Shadowheart has a rivalry attitude towards Lae'zel, heed to Lae'zel's advice will upset her.
Telling her she's hiding something in Camp conversation will result in her displeasure. If you choose to walk in on the two trolls having sex in the Blighted Village. Read the Necromancer of Thay from Search the Cellar.
(Upon speaking with Shadowheart after dream sequence) Say "The parasites have proved useful ..." when confronted by the camp. Give Oskar the artist gold after freeing him. Drink the wine prepared by Jaheira at the Last Light Inn
Give Gerringothethorm all your gold at the Reithwin Tollhouse Lick the Dead Spider meat in Gauntlet of Shar. Within the Gauntlet of Shar - Before entering the Shadowfell Entrance, peer inside her mind while she’s praying to Lady Shar.

 

Gale

Approval Up
Convince Rolan to stay in the Druid Grove. Calm the Scared Boar by the crash site (Animal Handling), or telling it to calm down (Speaks with Animals). Persuade Taman and Gimblebock to leave without a fight in dialogue outside the Crypt.
Agree to help Wyll save the refugees in the Druid Grove. Show Guex in the Druid Grove your sword fighting technique. Say that the Druids overreacted when speaking to Marriko and Locke in the Druid Grove.
Crush the Tadpole outside of the Druid Grove. Convince the Owlbear not to kill you in its cave. Tell Scratch (dog) that he can come to your Camp if his friend doesn't wake up.
Help Auntie Ethel when she's confronted by Johl and Demir. Tell Mayrina that her brothers are dead "by your own hand". Insist on helping Mayrina when talking to Auntie Ethel at her house.
Agree to help Zevlor. Refuse to play chicken chase with the owlbear in the Goblin Camp, then speak to it and give it your scent to follow to camp. Make Novice Crusher kiss your foot in the Goblin Camp (approval both for passing the check to tell him to, and also the check to actually make him kiss it).
Help Karlach in Hunt the Devil quest. Sympathetic behaviors. Fight the fake god Boooal in The Festering Cove.
(When discussing his "loss" around the campfire) Say "... I sympathize" When speaking with Eight (child on the far eastern side of the goblin camp), Say "Sorry for your loss" after asking about a corpse. Intimidate or persuade Zarys in the  Zhentarim hideout (i.e., tell her to stand down or say you don't want trouble).
Say you want to buy Oskar the artist in the Zhentarim hideout (“Fine, I’ll buy him. How much?”) and then successfully intimidate his slaver (Brem) Buy Oskar the artist. Give Oskar the artist gold after freeing him.
Tell Elminster, "If even the gods know, why are we facing these threats alone?" when he gives Gale his task for redemption While in Camp, tell Arabella you found her parents dead. Keep Scratch after discussing ownership of him at the Sword Coast couriers.

 

Approval Down
Join Lae'Zel against the Tieflings if you persuade them to free her. Smear dung on your face for Sentinel Olak. Read the Necromancy of Thay or give it to Gale
Agree to open the gate for goblin raiders. Threaten to smash the magic mirror during the Search the Cellar quest. (When discussing his "loss" around the campfire) Say "Another fool pays for his arrogance ..."

 

Lae'Zel

Approval Up
Show Guex in the Druid Grove your sword fighting technique (Athletics check). Choose to attack Taman and Gimblebock in dialogue outside the Crypt. (Astarion approves as well) When talking to Zevlor the first time inside the Druid Grove, tell him you're sorry but you have no time to help him.
During dialogue with Lae'zel, after she describes ceremorphosis, tell her you will find a cure. If Kagha's snake kills Arabella, tell her "She was just protecting her own." in dialogue afterward. Swear to Nettie you will take the poison.
Crush the Tadpole outside of the Druid Grove. Decline the Devil's invitation to remove your Tadpole. Respond to Volo in the Goblin Camp with "-"
Make Novice Crusher kiss your foot in the Goblin Camp (approval both for passing the check to tell him to, and also the check to actually make him kiss it)  Resist during the first dream sequence. Cruel behaviors.
Fight the fake god Boooal in The Festering Cove. Allowing her to speak to her githyanki brothers/sisters. Choosing Stay silent option when confronting Kagha about the fate of Arabella.
(Upon speaking with Shadowheart after dream sequence) Say "We should stop using the parasites ..." when confronted by the camp. Say you want to buy Oskar the artist in the Zhentarim hideout (“Fine, I’ll buy him. How much?”) and then successfully persuade or intimidate his slaver (Brem) After buying Oskar (which gives Lae'zel approval down), call him your slave and say you don't make jokes with your slaves.
Side with Elder Brithvar and kill Nere.  Deceive the Goblins and fling the poo at the four guards.  

 

Approval Down
Convince the Owlbear not to kill you in its cave. Try to persuade the goblin guard outside the Goblin Camp. Smear dung on your face for Sentinel Olak.
Tell Mayrina that her brothers are dead "by your own hand".

Agree to allow Auntie Ethel to remove your Tadpole.(After agreeing to allow Auntie Ethel to remove your Tadpole)

There appears to be further disapproval when you select the eye (doesn't matter if you choose the right or the left)

Lae'zel has a rivalry attitude towards Shadowheart, heed to Shadowheart's advice will upset her.
Sympathetic behaviors. Disapproves if you succeed in the persuasion check to stop Kagha from imprisoning the child. (Upon speaking with Shadowheart after the dream sequence) Say "The parasites have proved useful ..." when confronted by the camp.
Buy Oskar the artist.    

 

Wyll

Approval Up
Show Guex in the Druid Grove your sword fighting technique. Crush the Tadpole outside of the Druid Grove. Tell Scratch (dog) that he can come to your Camp if his friend doesn't wake up.
Try to persuade the goblin guard outside the Goblin Camp. Agree to fight Fezzerk in the Blighted Village. Decline the Devil's invitation to remove your Tadpole.
Agree to help Zevlor. Make Novice Crusher kiss your foot in the Goblin Camp (approval both for passing the check to tell him to, and also the check to actually make him kiss it)  Refuse to play chicken chase with the owlbear in the Goblin Camp, then speak to it and give it your scent to follow to camp.
Tell Mayrina that her brothers are dead "by your own hand" Insist on helping Mayrina when talking to Auntie Ethel at her house. Help Karlach in Hunt the Devil quest.
(Upon speaking with Shadowheart after dream sequence) Say "We should stop using the parasites ..." when confronted by the camp.  Say you want to buy Oskar the artist in the Zhentarim hideout (“Fine, I’ll buy him. How much?”) and then successfully persuade or intimidate his slaver (Brem) Buy Oskar the artist.
Give Oskar the artist gold after freeing him. Allow Wyll to play "how would you kill the Blade" when talking to three goblins in the Shattered Sanctum.  First time petting Scratch at Camp.
While in Camp, tell Arabella you found her parents dead. Keep Scratch after discussing ownership of him at the Sword Coast couriers.  

 

Approval Down
Smear dung on your face for Sentinel Olak. If you choose to walk in on the two trolls having sex in the Blighted Village.

Agree to allow Auntie Ethel to remove your Tadpole.(After agreeing to allow Auntie Ethel to remove your Tadpole)

There appears to be further disapproval when you select the eye (doesn't matter if you choose the right or the left)

Cruel Behaviors. Agree to open the gate for goblin raiders. He will leave you if side with the goblins.
Allow Fezzerk to live after questioning him. (Upon speaking with Shadowheart after dream sequence) Say "The parasites have proved useful ..." when confronted by the camp. After buying Oskar the artist in the Zhentarim hideout call him your slave and say you don't make jokes with your slaves.
Agree to help find the Zhentarim cargo for Zarys. Say that you need Astarion during the group meeting in the morning after he tries to bite you.  

 

Karlach

Approval Up
Release Dolly Dolly Dolly from the Moonlantern Play hide and seek with Oliver at the Ruined Battlefield Play another round of hide and seek with Oliver at the Ruined Battlefield
Tell Jaheira everything about the artefact Shuffle the lanceboard in the game between Mol and Raphael Drink the win prepared by Jaheira
Tell Isobel that Flaming Fist Marcus is trying to kidnap her Tell Arabella that you'll find her parents Drink or mime drinking with Thisobald Thorm at The Waning Moon
Tell Thisobald Thorm a story from your adventures at The Waning Moon Drink or mime drinking with Thisobald Thorm for a second round at The Waning Moon Tell Thisobald Thorm another story from your adventures at The Waning Moon
Drink or mime drinking with Thisobald Thorm for a third round at The Waning Moon Lick the Dead Spider meat within Gauntlet of Shar Upon finding Nightsong, tell Shadowheart to spare Nightsong and hear what she has to say
When Jaheira returns home, tell Rion "The cult is powerful- it's not going to be an easy fight."    

 

Approval Down
Give Gerringothe Thorm all your gold the Reithwin Tollhouse    
     



Tired of anon posting? Register!
    • Anonymous

      Grymforge

      After you talk to Philomeen
      Before clearing the rubbles
      Tell to Lunkbog and Laridda that Philomeen has decided to move on
      Karlach approves
      Lae'zel approves
      Astarion approves

      • Anonymous

        I feel like there is a lot of info not posted about Minthara when it comes to her approvals and disapprovals

        • Anonymous

          Act 3 - Lower City
          Sally Flymm : After a Wisdom check to "Probe her mind" telling her "So you're to blame for the rise of that charlatan" gives Karlach approval

          • Anonymous

            Act 3 - Lower City
            Araj Oblodra: If you gave her your blood / asked Astarion to bite her in Act 2 Moonrise Tower (idk how the dialogue changes if you didn't, but Astarion's dialogue if he's in your party doesn't want you to take her potion)
            - Telling her "Astarion, we can leave if you don't want to be around her" gives Karlach approval
            - Telling her "Our blood caused that explosion?" then "Forget it. I saw how you made Astarion feel. I'm done with you" gives Karlach approval

            You get a gold reward for drinking her potion though like 318gp

            • Anonymous

              If you convince the enchanted mirror in the basement of the blighted village to let you pass you gain approval with Astarion

              • Anonymous

                Act 3 - Lower City
                Investigate the Murders quest / Gauntlet Devella Fountainhead: After showing her the murder list, telling her "The Flaming Fist should be protecting everyone - not just Upper City folk" gives Karlach approval then telling her "I'll see what I can do" gives Karlach approval and Astarion disapproval

                • Anonymous

                  Act 3 - Wyrm's Rock
                  Gortash: Refusing his pact (saying "To the hells with your pact" then "You're on your own Gortash" gives Astarion, Wyll and Karlach approval

                  • Anonymous

                    Act 3
                    Wiki entry for [In the Fire First dorms, offer gold to Fist Reynash by saying "Will this get you home?"]. Karlach approves.
                    After succeeding a perception check that Fist Reynash has a lockpick and succeeding an Intimidation or Persuasion check,
                    Telling him "I need gold, too. Give me yours" gives Karlach and Wyll disapproval
                    Telling him "[Intimidation] Hand over everything you stole, and I'll let you live" gives Karlach and Wyll disapproval

                    • Anonymous

                      Two things I've found:

                      -If you say you need to save Nere/need the moonlantern when trying to open the gate to moonrise towers, Astarion AND Lae'zel will Disapprove.

                      -If you tell Nere to kill the slaves for the Absolute, Lae'zel, *not* Astarion, will approve. If you instead 'Say Nothing', Astarion will approve.

                      • Anonymous

                        Act 3
                        Wiki entry for [When Gortash invites you to watch the ceremony, choose the "I wouldn't dream of missing it."]. Wyll also disapproves when choosing this option.
                        Choosing option 3 "Fine. Let's get it over with" gives Wyll approval
                        Choosing option 4 "I have no interest in this sham of a ceremony" gives Wyll and Karlach approval

                        • Anonymous

                          Act 3 - Wyrm's Rock

                          "The High Harper" quest (Wyrm's Crossing) : When talking to Geraldus, tell Jaheira that it's her fault the harpers died and following up with dialogue option 1 or 2 gives approval

                          "Free Counsellor Florrick" quest (Wyrm's Rock Prison) : Persuading or Intimidating Florrick to get out of prison gives Karlach and Wyll approval. Completing the quest gives Karlach and Wyll approval

                          • Anonymous

                            Act I Underdark: Tell Sovereign/Mysterious Voice the truth about the parasite - Gale and Shadowheart approve. (Asterion does not react)

                            • Anonymous

                              At 1st long rest with Shadowheart dialogue, picking "Tell Shadowheart that you agree on needing to rapidly find a healer." only lists Lae'zel disapproval above, however it gives Shadowheart and Gale approval. Picking "we should be cautious" instead gives Astarion approval (listed above).

                              • Anonymous

                                "When meeting Ketheric Thorm and Z'Rell the first time, kill the goblins yourself by telling them they shouldn't breath anymore and choking them to death."
                                In this same scene, if you play as Dark Urge, When Fezzerk asks "Please - You Gotta Help Me! For old times' sake?"
                                Your options are:
                                1. Split yourselves open. Crack-Crack! And Smile while you work!
                                2. I dream of blood pools deep enough to bathe in. Run me a bath. - Astarion Approves
                                3. BEG! CHOKE! DIE!
                                4. I will do this by my own hands, it always feels better.
                                5. Put aside your torments. Free them.
                                No idea what the approval is on the rest of these yet though.

                                • Anonymous

                                  In Camp (Triggered Cutscene) Astarion is seen reading the Necromancy of Thay Book
                                  On the Third Dialogue, He disapproves if you respond with:
                                  "Gale would take it off your hands."
                                  "Stop Reading It"

                                  Staying Silent also has the funniest option for the first dialogue.

                                  • Anonymous

                                    In the Goblin camp, the Giant Spiders in the pens (behind where you can find True Soul Gut) can be persuaded to eat goblins instead (animal speech) - Gale and Shadowheart Approve. Karlach Doesn't approve but she doesn't disapprove either.

                                    • Anonymous

                                      Act I Underdark - Beach: Gale approves if you attack Gekh Coal. (Astarian and Shadowheart had no reaction. Others unknown)

                                      • For "Tell the True Soul Gut 'Change of plans, I'm going to kill you' after following her to somewhere private," Shadowheart also approves and Karlach is neutral.

                                        • Anonymous

                                          Act 3 - Rivington
                                          Saer Grotpoll: Telling him you're Baldurian and then saying out with the refugees gives Astarion and Halsin disapproval and Jaheira neutral. Telling him his accent is Rivingtonian gives Jaheira approval.

                                          • Anonymous

                                            Act 3 - Camp
                                            Jaheira approval:
                                            Tell her, "Please. You're only one of those things", after asking that she has fought the Dead Three before
                                            Tell her, "My mind is my own", when asking about what she knows about Illithids

                                            • Anonymous

                                              Act 2 (after freeing Mizora and killing Ketheric Thorm)
                                              Talking to Wyll: opening your mind to him to let him show you his memory, telling him it was a brave choice and a frightening one, telling him it was a brave thing what he did for the city gives approval

                                              • Anonymous

                                                Act 2 - Moonrise Towers
                                                After killing Ketheric Thorm, if you reunited Oliver and Thaniel, talking to Thaniel in Moonrise (he's beside a pillar near Withers, didn't even really notice him until he noticed my cat familiar) will give 20 Halsin approval (the dialogue options don't seem to matter as long as you talk to him)

                                                • Anonymous

                                                  Meeting Karlach, saying 'can't you see she's not the devil...?' nets an approval from Karlach, Shadowheart, and surprisingly, Astarion.

                                                  • Anonymous

                                                    Outside of the Blighted Village, there's a barn which makes some rhythmic....thumping noises. Sounds like someone's having a bit of fun. You can open the door: out of my party Wyll and Shadowheart disapprove, Astarion approves. Same result if you call out first and then let Astarion open the door, though that option is funny xD

                                                    • Anonymous

                                                      in act 2 in shars gauntlet, succeed a passuve insight check while talking to yurgir after hearing his song' convince him to kill his minions, his displacer beast, and then himself. astarion will approve (not sure about others)

                                                      • Anonymous

                                                        After Exposing Kagha's Conspiracy, convince Kagha to side against the Shadow Druids

                                                        Wyll +
                                                        Karlach +

                                                        info lacks

                                                        Gale +

                                                        all 3 of them approve

                                                        • Anonymous

                                                          At a camp when reading the Infernal on Astorians back, if you make the joke about what it says, he disapproves.

                                                          • Anonymous

                                                            If you tell Mayrena “it’s better than nothing” when she gives you the locket after the Hag battle. Shadowheart will approve.

                                                            • Anonymous

                                                              Telling Minthara that Sazza "didn't know" (needed for "she cannot be caged" achievement) gives Karlach approval, and Astarion, Lae'zel and Wyll disapproval.

                                                              Telling Minthara you agree to assault the grove gives Astarion approval, and Gale & Karlach disapproval.

                                                              • Anonymous

                                                                Angleiron’s Cellar, Wulbren Bongle: Get the bomb inside the Gondian facility, and - boom. Problem solved.
                                                                [Rogue] Sneak in, place the bomb, sneak out - bang. Sounds simple enough
                                                                + Jahira
                                                                - Karlach
                                                                - Halsin
                                                                + Wyll
                                                                No response: Lae’zel, Astarion, Gale, Shadowheart

                                                                • Anonymous

                                                                  Persuading deep Rothe to attack Duergar masters in Grymforge gives Wyll approval (I had Karlach, Wyll, Shadowheart in the party and all 3 approved).

                                                                  • Anonymous

                                                                    In act 3, after Astarion's siblings confront you in your camp, you get approval if you tell him "The world can be a wonderful, kind place". I'm not sure if you have to fight the siblings. I did and then called him out for trying to deceive them and asking if he had sympathy for those who shared his plight.

                                                                    • Anonymous

                                                                      In meeting the Harpers, when Lassandra asks “who’s there?!”, choosing the bard option "I find the best introductions are made while sitting around a fire, perhaps with drinks?" - Wyll and Karlach approve, Astarion disproves
                                                                      Choosing the option "A nightmare in the dark" - Astarion approves

                                                                      • Anonymous

                                                                        Saving Arabella from Kagha via Paladin judgment only gets approval from Gale. Neither Wyll nor Shadowheart approve in this case.

                                                                        • Anonymous

                                                                          Act 3 outside of Sword Coast Couriers
                                                                          Angry Mar'hyah keep responding with "Woof!" approval up for Shadowheart and Astarion

                                                                          • Anonymous

                                                                            This whole approval/disapproval mechanic really doesn't seem very well thought out. For example. All my party members will comment we need to confront someone, then proceed to disapprove the moment we confront them. It contradicts everything they just said.

                                                                            • Anonymous

                                                                              After you defeat Ketheric Throm, talk to Art Cullagh in Moonrise Towers and say "I just killed Kethric and this is all you have to say?"
                                                                              Astarion APPROVES +
                                                                              Halsin DISAPPROVES -

                                                                              • Anonymous

                                                                                Act 2 - Gauntlet of Shar
                                                                                After telling Yurgir you'll look for a way to break his contract, talk to him again and talk about the Displacer Beast then telling him that it's wrong to manipulate the beast in such a way will give Shadowheart approval and Halsin approval
                                                                                (I think you have to know that the Displacer Beast is being charmed by either detecting the thoughts of the Merregon trader or passing the checks on the spider carcass then talking to the Displacer beast with Talk to Animals)

                                                                                • Anonymous

                                                                                  If you meet Auntie Ethel in her little tent in the tiefling's camp (Druid's Grove - The Hollow) prior to wandering into the wetlands, she'll ask you if there's anything wrong with you. If you chose the top option at some point, I think it's the second dialogue option (something along the lines of "It's difficult to explain") you'll get a beat of commentary from Shadowheart, Lae'zel or Astarion (Or those were the three that piped up for me). Lae'zel or Shadowheart will tell you not to say anything to Auntie Ethel, and if you do tell Auntie about the parasite, you'll get disapproval from whichever one of them spoke up, and a point of approval from Astarion if he's in your party. If Astarion is in your party without the other two, he'll gleefully tell you to tell Auntie Ethel everything, and you'll get approval from him. If you listen to Lae'zel/Shadowhearts warnings, it seems like you don't get any approval from either of them, and you don't get anything from taking most of the other dialogue options from what I was able to find.

                                                                                  • Anonymous

                                                                                    Grymforge - Tell Ward Magmar that he disgusts you: Karlach and Wyll approves. Astarion disapproves. Lae'zel and Shadowheart have no reaction. Gale had no reaction either but I don't know if it's because he doesn't care or because his relationship was already at max so there was no room for more approval.

                                                                                    • Anonymous

                                                                                      Last Light Inn, declining the drink from Jaheira gives approval+ for Astarion and Lae'Zel.
                                                                                      Also, if you talk to the cat (His Majesty) in the inn, and compliment him / just admire him silently, Astarion approves as well.

                                                                                      • Anonymous

                                                                                        At the Last Light Inn:
                                                                                        Astarion Approves if you:
                                                                                        Persuade the cat that you were only trying to admire it and then quietly admire it
                                                                                        Keep the Strange Ox's Secret
                                                                                        Manipulate the game board in Mol's favor

                                                                                        • Anonymous

                                                                                          Githyanki Crest: Pass the Persuasion check and then tell Varsh Ko Kuu "I will make the best omelette you've ever tasted.". = Astarion approval. Karlach + Shadowheart disapproval. lol

                                                                                          • Anonymous

                                                                                            Letting Mayrina know Ethel killed her brothers gives approval from Gale, Wyll and Karlach. I don't know about the others.

                                                                                            • Anonymous

                                                                                              In Shadowlands:
                                                                                              When encountering Malus Thorm, recall what you know of Shar's teachings (High Religion Check), then persuade him to volunteer for the sisters (Persuasion 21).

                                                                                              Shadowheart APPROVES
                                                                                              Karlach APPROVES
                                                                                              Astarion APPROVES

                                                                                              Untested with other companions.

                                                                                              • Anonymous

                                                                                                MOUNTAIN PASS (ROSYMORN MONASTERY AND CRÈCHE Y'LLEK)
                                                                                                In start of the map when lacel says that they should head streight to monestary, then if you tell her to wait and then afterword tell her to join again then she will say something partly, if you then ask what she was trying to say she say no, but then you can persuade her to say what it is. she say she was glad he came back and then you can say you are too (or something like that) it will Karlach approve and shadowhard desaprove.

                                                                                                • Anonymous

                                                                                                  Act 1, the Risen Road. [Cleric] option of blessing the hyena gives approval from Gale. None of the other companions have a reaction (I don't know about Karlach though, she wasn't in my party yet).

                                                                                                  • Anonymous

                                                                                                    Act 2 - Ruined Battlefield
                                                                                                    In meeting the Harpers, when Lassandra asks “who’s there?!”, choosing option 4 "[Druid] Peace - I am a druid", gives Astarion disapproval

                                                                                                    • Anonymous

                                                                                                      Didn't see this looking but when you're first talking to Wyll in the Druid Grove, Lae'zel will disapprove if you say "let's join forces."

                                                                                                      • Anonymous

                                                                                                        In Shadowlands:
                                                                                                        When encountering Gerringothe Thorm in the tollhouse, tell them you've come to replace them (Deception 18). Then tell them they're getting promoted (Deception 21).

                                                                                                        Shadowheart APPROVES
                                                                                                        Karlach APPROVES
                                                                                                        Astarion APPROVES

                                                                                                        Have not tested on other companions.

                                                                                                        • Anonymous

                                                                                                          In underdark:
                                                                                                          When you are asked by by Glut, wether you wonna help him take the power of the spore colony, then if you reply that you wont pick a side / dont have apart of it. that will give aprovel by Lazel

                                                                                                          • Anonymous

                                                                                                            After the second dream visitor dream, talk to Lae'zel and agree with her (tell her you won't use the tadpoles), she approves

                                                                                                            • Anonymous

                                                                                                              Act 1 - Zhentarim Hideout. Intimidate Zarys upon arrival. Karlach and Shadowheart approves. Lae'zel and Astarion have no reaction. I don't know about Wyll and Gale.

                                                                                                              • Anonymous

                                                                                                                When meeting Ketheric Thorm and Z'Rell the first time,

                                                                                                                Fezzerk: Please - You Gotta Help Me! For old times' sake?
                                                                                                                Tell him to "Spill your guts on the floor. I want to see you bleed.

                                                                                                                Astarion Approves

                                                                                                                • Anonymous

                                                                                                                  If Marcus come to your aid when you encounter the Harper group at the inn for the first time then later you can expose him. For optimal approval first tell him that his mission ends now, then tell him to deal with it on his own(this doesnt increase or decrease approval just need to start the conversation with the cleric). You will then move to Isobel to talk to her. Expose Marcus right away and then say that you mean it after Marcus tries to convince you. This triggers the fight. Everyone will like that including Halsin and Minthara except Astarion who will dislike everytime you go against Marcus wishes.
                                                                                                                  TLDR: you can get 3 approval up with everyone except Astarion if you are difficult when talking to Marcus and then expose him.

                                                                                                                  Also Minthara also likes it when you refuse to drink the wine Jaheira offers.

                                                                                                                  • Anonymous

                                                                                                                    "The Gith Patrol With Lae'zel leading the conversation, win the Persuasion Check and Lae'zel wins her Deceit Check in the convo with Kith'rak Voss"
                                                                                                                    shadowheart aproves as well

                                                                                                                    • Anonymous

                                                                                                                      Disguise as a Gith and then talk to Ellyka and say "Relax, it's just a disguise" and then "no you are safe"

                                                                                                                      Shadowheart aprrove as well

                                                                                                                      • Anonymous

                                                                                                                        Act 1 - Forest (near the Blighted Village)

                                                                                                                        Telling Scratch that he can join your camp if his master doesn't wake up grants approval from Karlach, Shadowheart and Wyll. Lae'zel and Astarion have no reaction. I don't know about Gale.

                                                                                                                        • Anonymous

                                                                                                                          You have resources to spare - give me something to aid my search

                                                                                                                          This will ask Balthazar to give you the Flesh Bell

                                                                                                                          Astarion Approves

                                                                                                                          • Anonymous

                                                                                                                            Act 2 - Do not get caught by Oliver's "family" - If you don't get caught and find Oliver, Astarion Approves.

                                                                                                                            • Anonymous

                                                                                                                              Act 3: in the circus, if you send a companion on stage, they will disapprove, but the rest of the party will approve. I found this hilarious how they like to humiliate each other, like true friends :D

                                                                                                                              • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                Halsin approval: Would like to note something in the scene when you're convincing Oliver to go back to Thaniel -- it seems that convincing Oliver on your own gives 45 approval while telling Halsin to talk to him gives 50 ( that's what I got trying different options)

                                                                                                                                • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                  After defeating Nere together with Elder Brithvar persuade him to leave the Gnomes behind - Astarian disapproves

                                                                                                                                  • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                    Use the option the Deception option with Topaz the Bird

                                                                                                                                    Pretty Straight forward. Win the Deception Roll
                                                                                                                                    Karlach +
                                                                                                                                    Shadowheart +

                                                                                                                                    Druid's Grove - The little nest on the ground next to the elevator.

                                                                                                                                    • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                      Will also approves if you agree to play with Oliver- Karlach, Will, and Shadowheart approve again when you agree to play with him again, too.

                                                                                                                                      • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                        Lump the Enlightened: when he comes to collect the money if you made a deal with him (he came to my camp in Act 2), paying him and then letting him lick your arm gives Astarion approval and Shadowheart approval

                                                                                                                                        • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                          Act 1, Githyanki Egg Nursery: Tell the egg keeper (Vash Ko'kuu) that you will raise the young as your own OR that you will take it to another githyanki's nursery. In both cases, Astarion expresses his disapproval.

                                                                                                                                          • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                            Convince the hyena to run away from the goblins (Shadow-cursed lands) - Karlach and Astarion approve. You need to pass 2x checks.

                                                                                                                                            • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                              Act 2 - Last Light Inn
                                                                                                                                              First meeting with Jaheira: when she asks why you have come to Last Light Inn, telling her "I'm here on holiday" gives Astarion approval

                                                                                                                                              • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                                At Candulhallow’s Tombstones, if you bring Jaheira with you, Sarevok whats your goal by bringing he's enemy there and the narrator tells there is a great tension on the room and none of them will allow the other leave the room alive. All your companions will approve if you ask Jaheira with she wants to kill Sarevok herself or if you may as well do it.

                                                                                                                                                • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                                  Act 2 - Ruined Battlefield
                                                                                                                                                  In meeting with Lassandra (Harpers scout people), when Yonas comes back as a zombie, choosing option 4, "Run", gives Astarion approval and Gale disapproval

                                                                                                                                                  • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                                    Creche Y'llek - After observing the comet on the Small Portrait of Vlaakith, speak to Youth Varrl in the classroom. After passing some conversation checks, Varrl will give you an Orpheus book which gives Lae'zel approval.

                                                                                                                                                    • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                                      Githyanki Crest: Pass the Persuasion check and then tell Varsh Ko Kuu you will raise the egg/child as your own. = Astarion disapproves (-1)

                                                                                                                                                      • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                                        Drink from the well outside of auntie Ethel's place: Lae'zel approves, together with Gale (above only mentions Gale).

                                                                                                                                                        • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                                          Act 3, In the Open Hand Temple to Ilmater :
                                                                                                                                                          - Astarion Disapproves of telling Tara to stop eating the pigeons
                                                                                                                                                          - Halsin Approves of telling Tara to stop eating the pigeons

                                                                                                                                                        Load more
                                                                                                                                                        ⇈ ⇈